Aer Lingus pilots initiated work-to-rule in pursuit of a 24% pay rise.
Hundreds of flights have been cancelled due to the work-to-rule action.
IALPA members began this action after separate meetings at the Labour Court in Dublin failed to reach a resolution.
In a recent development, Aer Lingus pilots have initiated an indefinite work-to-rule in pursuit of a 24% pay rise. The Irish Air Line Pilots' Association (IALPA) members began this action after separate meetings at the Labour Court in Dublin failed to reach a resolution. This comes as hundreds of flights have been cancelled, causing significant disruption for passengers. Aer Lingus expressed disappointment that the Labour Court did not intervene in the dispute but will review the matter in July. The airline urges IALPA to prioritize reaching a fair agreement and minimize customer disruption.
Aer Lingus pilots have begun industrial action in an ongoing dispute with the airline over pay.
IALPA are seeking a 24% pay rise.
Accuracy
The total number of flights cancelled as a result of the industrial action has now risen to 270.
Deception
(100%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Fallacies
(75%)
The author does not commit any formal or informal fallacies in the article. However, there is a dichotomous depiction and an appeal to authority. The dichotomous depiction is presented when the author states that “Aer Lingus said it has made it clear that it remains available for discussions both directly and through the state’s industrial relations framework”. This implies that IALPA is unwilling to engage in discussions, which may not be accurate. The appeal to authority occurs when the author quotes Taoiseach Simon Harris and Tánaiste Micheál Martin without critically evaluating their statements. No specific fallacies are found in the direct quotes from IALPA president Capt Mark Tighe.
Aer Lingus said it has made it clear that it remains available for discussions both directly and through the state's industrial relations framework.
Aer Lingus pilots have begun an indefinite ‘strict work to rule’ in pursuit of a 24% pay claim.
Members of the Irish Air Line Pilots’ Association (Ialpa) will also walk out on strike from 5am to 1pm on Saturday 29 June.
Talks at the Labour Court in Dublin failed to make any progress in the dispute and hundreds of flights have been cancelled.
Direct Aer Lingus UK services from Manchester across the Atlantic and Aer Lingus Regional operation provided by a separate carrier, Emerald Airlines, are unaffected.
The dispute is about a 24% pay claim which pilots say equates to inflation since the last wage rise in 2019.
Aer Lingus says profitability levels in the company are the lowest in the IAG group and investing profits in pilot pay is unsustainable.
Pilots will refuse any flexibility with their work, including not working overtime or answering phone calls outside of work hours.
Accuracy
IALPA are seeking a 24% pay rise.
Deception
(50%)
The article contains selective reporting as it only reports details that support the author's position. The author quotes Captain Mark Tighe making statements about Aer Lingus profits and pay claims without providing any context or counterargument from Aer Lingus management. The article also implies that Aer Lingus is not investing in the business, but does not provide any evidence to support this claim.
Aer Lingus says it hoped to ‘continue to engage in meaningful direct discussions on productivity and flexibility proposals to enable increased pay’ but Ialpa refused it.
In response to the work to rule, Aer Lingus has cancelled an average of 26 flights per day during the first week of the action (with many more on the day of the strike).
Captain Mark Tighe, president of Ialpa, says the pay claim simply equates to inflation since the last wage rise in 2019.
Members of the Irish Air Line Pilots’ Association (Ialpa) will also walk out on strike from 5am to 1pm on Saturday 29 June, aiming to disrupt the start of the school holiday exodus for many families.
The airline also says the union’s ‘failure to engage in the various independent processes in a responsible manner jeopardises our growth plans including our plans to fly to more destinations'
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains several examples of inflammatory rhetoric and appeals to authority. The author states that “Aer Lingus have increased their profits by 400% to €255m [£216m] last year” and accuses the airline of insisting pilots “sell their working conditions in exchange for any increase in pay.
The author also quotes Captain Tighe as saying: “We are absolutely not prepared to do that, especially when Aer Lingus is making enormous profits.” This inflammatory language creates a hostile tone and encourages readers to take sides. Additionally, the author appeals to authority by quoting Ialpa's claims about the pay dispute and Aer Lingus' financial situation. These fallacies do not constitute a majority of the article, but they are still present and impactful.
Aer Lingus have increased their profits by 400% to €255m [£216m] last year
We are absolutely not prepared to do that, especially when Aer Lingus is making enormous profits.
Captain Tighe says: “We are absolutely not prepared to do that, especially when Aer Lingus is making enormous profits.”
Bias
(80%)
The author expresses a clear bias towards the pilots and their union (Ialpa) in their dispute with Aer Lingus management. The author quotes Captain Mark Tighe, president of Ialpa, extensively and does not provide any counterpoint from Aer Lingus management. The author also uses language that depicts Aer Lingus management as insisting pilots 'sell their working conditions in exchange for any increase in pay' and accuses them of 'failing to provide a meaningful offer on pay'. The author also implies that the union's demands are reasonable by stating that the pilots are 'absolutely not prepared to do that, especially when Aer Lingus is making enormous profits.'
Captain Tighe accuses Aer Lingus management of insisting pilots ‘sell their working conditions in exchange for any increase in pay.’
Captain Tighe says: ‘We are in this position because management have failed to provide us with a meaningful offer on pay that accounts for inflation and the sacrifices made by pilots to save Aer Lingus during the pandemic.’
The airline says it hoped to ‘continue to engage in meaningful direct discussions on productivity and flexibility proposals to enable increased pay’ but Ialpa refused it.
:quality(70)/cloudfront-eu-central-1.images.arcpublishing.com/irishtimes/SSBQBZT373YFM6GELJAS3LI7IQ.jpg)
:quality(70)/cloudfront-eu-central-1.images.arcpublishing.com/irishtimes/SSBQBZT373YFM6GELJAS3LI7IQ.jpg)
