Bangladesh's Controversial Quota System: Protests, Deaths, and Deep-rooted Political Divides

Dhaka, Bangladesh Bangladesh
. Over 100 deaths and hundreds of injuries have resulted from clashes between students and police during the protests.
. The Bangladesh Supreme Court's decision to reinstate a quota system for civil service jobs has sparked violent protests in the country.
The quota system was abolished in 2018 due to widespread student-led protests but has now been reinstated by the Supreme Court.
Bangladesh's Controversial Quota System: Protests, Deaths, and Deep-rooted Political Divides

Bangladesh has been embroiled in violent protests since the beginning of July, following the Bangladesh Supreme Court's decision to reinstate a controversial quota system for civil service jobs. The quota system, which previously allocated 30% of civil service positions to veterans and their relatives, was abolished in 2018 due to widespread student-led protests. However, the court's ruling sparked renewed demonstrations and clashes between students and police.

The protests have resulted in over 100 deaths and injured hundreds of people. The German Foreign Office has advised its citizens against traveling to Bangladesh due to the violent clashes and a curfew that is currently in place. The US State Department has also issued a travel advisory, urging Americans to reconsider their travel plans.

The protests began after the High Court reinstated the quota system, which many young people feel disadvantages them. The Supreme Court's decision came despite widespread opposition from students and civil society groups. The Awami League party, which is in power, has defended the quota system as a way to recognize the contributions of those who fought for Bangladesh's independence during the 1971 war.

The protests have been ongoing for over a month, with no signs of abating. Soldiers have been deployed across cities in Bangladesh and a stay-at-home order has been in place since Tuesday. The government has declared Sunday and Monday as public holidays, with only emergency services allowed to operate.

The quota system was first introduced in 1972, reserving 30% of seats in public-sector jobs and higher education institutions for freedom fighters. However, critics argue that it perpetuates nepotism and undermines meritocracy. The protests have highlighted deep-rooted political divides between competing goals and principles in Bangladeshi society.

Bangladesh gained independence with a sense of hard dichotomies between democracy vs economic development, political participation vs national integration, liberty vs equality, and pro-liberation vs anti-liberation forces. Protests in Bangladesh are often driven by long-standing ideological differences between political parties. Students have been at the center of crucial movements in Bangladeshi history, including the Language Movement and the Liberation War.

The current protests were spearheaded by left-wing and liberal student groups, as well as the main opposition party, Bangladesh National Party (BNP). The quota system was introduced in Bangladesh in 1972 and mandated that 30% of seats in public-sector jobs and higher education institutions be reserved for freedom fighters. Protests against the quota system began in 2018 and successfully pressured the government to discontinue it, but it was reinstated by the Supreme Court in June 2023.

Violence erupted between pro-government student groups and anti-quota demonstrators, resulting in over 100 deaths and over 2,500 injuries. The government has agreed to do away with the quota system but students are demanding an immediate legislative resolution.

The protests have also highlighted the deep-rooted political divides in Bangladeshi society. The Awami League party, which is in power, has defended the quota system as a way to recognize the contributions of those who fought for Bangladesh's independence during the 1971 war. However, critics argue that it perpetuates nepotism and undermines meritocracy.

The protests have also raised questions about Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's leadership and her commitment to democratic values. The Awami League party has been in power since 2009, and some critics argue that the government has become increasingly authoritarian under her tenure.

Despite the violence and political turmoil, Bangladesh remains an important player in the global community. It is a member of the United Nations, the World Bank, and other international organizations. The country is also home to a large and growing economy, with a GDP of over $300 billion.

The protests are likely to continue for some time, as both sides dig in their heels and refuse to back down. It remains to be seen how the government will respond and whether it will be able to find a peaceful resolution that addresses the concerns of all parties involved.



Confidence

90%

Doubts
  • How accurate are the death toll and injury numbers?
  • Is there a possibility that the protests could lead to political unrest or instability in Bangladesh?

Sources

98%

  • Unique Points
    • The Bangladesh supreme court has overturned job quotas that previously allocated 30% of civil service jobs to veterans and relatives of those who fought in the 1971 Bangladesh war of independence.
    • Widespread student-led protests and violent clashes occurred after the court's decision.
    • More than 100 people have been killed during the protests.
  • Accuracy
    • Bangladesh’s top court has scaled back the controversial quota system for government job applicants from 30% to 5%.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

94%

  • Unique Points
    • Bangladesh’s top court has scaled back the controversial quota system for government job applicants from 30% to 5%.
    • Protests have been ongoing since June after the High Court reinstated the quotas following a halt in 2018.
    • At least over 100 people have been reported killed during the protests.
    • Violence between students and police escalated on Tuesday with tear gas, rubber bullets and smoke grenades used to disperse crowds.
    • The protests turned deadly on Tuesday with reports of over 100 deaths.
    • Soldiers have patrolled cities across Bangladesh and a stay-at-home order has been in place since then.
    • The government has declared Sunday and Monday as public holidays with only emergency services allowed to operate.
  • Accuracy
    • More than 100 people have died during the demonstrations and protests in Bangladesh.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (75%)
    The article contains a few informal fallacies and appeals to authority. It does not contain any formal logical fallacies. The author reports on the ruling of Bangladesh's Supreme Court regarding the quota system for government jobs, detailing the history of the issue and its implications. However, there are instances where statements from authorities or experts are presented without critical analysis.
    • . . . students, frustrated by shortages of good jobs, have been demanding an end to a quota that reserved 30% of government jobs for relatives of veterans who fought in Bangladesh’s war of independence in 1971.
    • The protests have posed the most serious challenge to Bangladesh’s government since Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina won a fourth consecutive term in January elections that the main opposition groups boycotted.
    • Law Minister Anisul Haq of the ruling Awami League party also welcomed the court’s decision and said it
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

96%

  • Unique Points
    • German Foreign Office has advised citizens against traveling to Bangladesh due to violent clashes and a curfew in place.
    • More than 100 people have died during the demonstrations and protests in Bangladesh.
    • A new curfew was imposed on Friday in Bangladesh following country-wide protests over the reinstatement of a controversial civil service job quota system.
    • Mass protests began in early July as many young people feel they are at a disadvantage due to the quota system.
    • The Supreme Court weakened the plan for reintroducing the system on Sunday, but student leaders are not satisfied with the changes.
  • Accuracy
    • More than 100 people have died during the protests.
    • The old quota system reserves more than half of the civil service positions for specific groups in Bangladesh.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The article contains a few informal fallacies and an appeal to authority. It also uses inflammatory rhetoric by mentioning the number of people who have died during the protests. No formal logical fallacies are present.
    • . The German Foreign Office has advised citizens to avoid travel to Bangladesh.
    • . More than 100 people have already died during the demonstrations and protests.
    • The US State Department had also warned Americans on Saturday not to travel to Bangladesh and announced it would begin removing some diplomats and their families from the country.
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

78%

  • Unique Points
    • Bangladesh gained independence with a sense of hard dichotomies between competing goals and principles.
    • Protests in Bangladesh are often driven by long-standing ideological differences between political parties.
    • Students have been at the center of crucial movements in Bangladeshi history, including the Language Movement and the Liberation War.
    • The current protests were spearheaded by left-wing and liberal student groups, as well as the main opposition party, Bangladesh National Party (BNP).
    • The quota system was introduced in Bangladesh in 1972 and mandated that 30% of seats in public-sector jobs and higher education institutions be reserved for freedom fighters.
    • Protests against the quota system began in 2018 and successfully pressured the government to discontinue it, but it was reinstated by the Supreme Court in June 2023.
    • Violence erupted between pro-government student groups and anti-quota demonstrators, resulting in over 100 deaths and over 2,500 injuries.
    • The government has agreed to do away with the quota system but students are demanding an immediate legislative resolution.
  • Accuracy
    No Contradictions at Time Of Publication
  • Deception (10%)
    The author uses emotional manipulation by invoking the term 'razakars' to compare those opposed to the quota system with collaborators of Pakistani forces during Bangladesh's struggle for liberation. This is a deceptive tactic as it aims to evoke negative emotions towards those opposing the quota system, rather than engaging in a rational discussion about the merits and demerits of the policy.
    • The protesters have also been compared to 'razakars' by Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina.
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The author makes use of dichotomous depictions by describing Bangladesh's politics as being divided between two zero-sum options. This can be seen in the examples provided such as 'democracy vs economic development', 'political participation vs national integration', and 'liberty vs equality'. The author also uses an appeal to authority when referencing the Supreme Court's decision to reinstate the quota system and the constitutional articles that support it. No explicit fallacies were found, but this article scores a 85 due to the presence of these implicit fallacies.
    • ]There is a sense of hard dichotomies, of the people choosing between two zero-sum options that permeates Bangladesh’s politics.[
    • In the ongoing anti-quota protests, too, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has invoked ‘liberation’ by comparing those opposed to her policy with ‘razakars’ – a pejorative epithet for those who collaborated with Pakistani forces during the country’s struggle for liberation.
    • The students have been demanding that the system be reformed. In 2018, they carried out massive protests and successfully pressured the government to discontinue the quota system. The current trouble began on June 5, when the High Court Division of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh nullified the government’s decision to scrap the quota system. It reinstated 30 per cent reservations for freedom fighters and their progeny.
  • Bias (95%)
    The author uses the term 'razakars' to describe those opposed to the government's policy, which is a pejorative term with historical significance as it refers to collaborators with Pakistani forces during Bangladesh's struggle for liberation. This language implies that those opposing the quota system are unpatriotic and anti-liberation, creating a negative connotation.
    • The protesters have also been compared to 'razakars' by Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina.
    • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication
    • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication

    92%

    • Unique Points
      • The U.S. State Department has raised the travel advisory level for Bangladesh amid civil unrest in the South Asia country.
    • Accuracy
      • Police have imposed a strict curfew with a 'shoot-on-sight' curfew amid protests.
    • Deception (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication
    • Fallacies (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication
    • Bias (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication
    • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication
    • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication