Bird Flu Virus in US Dairy Cattle: FDA Urges States to Stop Sale of Raw Milk Amid Contamination Concerns

Dallas County, Texas United States of America
Bird flu virus detected in dairy cattle in US
CDC advises against consuming raw milk due to health risks
FDA recommends states use regulatory authorities to stop sale of raw milk in infected areas and test herds for signs of illness and H5N1 virus
FDA urges states to stop sale of raw milk due to potential contamination
From 1998 through 2018 there were 202 outbreaks linked to drinking raw milk causing 2,645 illnesses and 228 hospitalizations
Latest diet trend involves consuming raw milk which can carry foodborne illnesses such as salmonella, E. coli, listeria and campylobacter bacteria
People unclear if they can get bird flu from drinking contaminated milk but cats and dairy workers have fallen ill or died after exposure
Raw milk can carry H5N1 bird flu virus through udders
Several states report infected herds including Minnesota, Iowa, and Wyoming
Some small dairies continue to sell raw milk despite warnings
Bird Flu Virus in US Dairy Cattle: FDA Urges States to Stop Sale of Raw Milk Amid Contamination Concerns

Bird flu, a highly contagious virus that has been spreading among dairy cattle in the US, has raised concerns about the safety of raw milk. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is urging states to take action against the sale of raw milk due to potential contamination with the bird flu virus. This comes as several states, including Minnesota, Iowa, and Wyoming, have reported infected herds.

Raw milk can carry high levels of the H5N1 bird flu virus because it infects cows through their udders. While it is not yet clear whether people can get bird flu by drinking contaminated milk, cats and dairy workers have fallen ill or died after being exposed to infected raw milk.

The FDA has recommended that states use their regulatory authorities to stop the sale of raw milk within their borders where dairy herds have tested positive for the virus. The agency also advised states to test herds for signs of illness and implement surveillance testing for H5N1 in dairy herds producing raw milk.

Despite these warnings, some small dairies continue to sell raw milk, citing consumer demand and state laws that limit state oversight of sales. For instance, Simply Living Homestead dairy in Dallas County is dealing with the concern of bird flu transmission in their raw milk sales. The owner Amanda Carlin stated that she gives her herd a warm water and soap bath before milking to ensure their health.

The latest diet trend on social media involves consuming raw, or unpasteurized, milk. However, experts warn against this practice due to the potential risks of foodborne illnesses such as salmonella, E. coli, listeria and campylobacter bacteria that can be present in raw milk.

From 1998 through 2018, there were 202 outbreaks linked to drinking raw milk that caused 2,645 illnesses and 228 hospitalizations. Pasteurization prevents these diseases by killing harmful bacteria in the milk.

The CDC advises against consuming raw milk due to these health risks. Additionally, an outbreak of bird flu affecting cow herds in the US has led to high levels of the virus in raw milk from infected cows, posing a potential risk for those who consume it.

It is important for consumers to be aware of these risks and make informed choices about their food sources. The FDA encourages states to take action against the sale of raw milk and implement surveillance testing to protect public health.



Confidence

91%

Doubts
  • Are there any studies or data on the exact number of cases where people have gotten sick from consuming contaminated raw milk and bird flu?
  • Is it definitively proven that people can get bird flu from drinking contaminated raw milk?
  • What is the current status of surveillance testing for H5N1 in dairy herds producing raw milk?

Sources

84%

  • Unique Points
    • Amanda Carlin, owner of Simply Living Homestead dairy, gives her herd a warm water and soap bath before milking.
    • Simply Living Homestead dairy in Dallas County is dealing with the concern of bird flu transmission in their raw milk sales.
  • Accuracy
    • ]The Food and Drug Administration is asking states to discourage raw milk sales due to a new fear it could transmit bird flu.[
    • Bird flu cases have been detected in dairy cattle in Wyoming, Iowa, and Minnesota.
    • Three human cases of bird flu have been tied to dairy cattle outbreaks.
  • Deception (70%)
    The author does not make any clear attempts at emotional manipulation or sensationalism in this article. However, there are instances of selective reporting and potential misinformation. The author quotes state Sen. Claire Celsi expressing her concerns about raw milk sales and the potential for bird flu transmission, but does not provide any context or counterargument from other experts or scientific studies to challenge her perspective. Additionally, the author states that 'Carlin is staying out of politics' but then goes on to quote Rep. Bobby Kaufmann's stance on raw milk sales, implying that he supports fewer restrictions despite not providing any evidence of this beyond his own words.
    • He told KCCI he’s doubling down and wants fewer restrictions on raw milk sales.
    • state Sen. Claire Celsi hopes Republican lawmakers realize what she calls their hasty mistake.
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

98%

  • Unique Points
    • Bird flu cases have been detected in dairy cattle in Wyoming, Iowa, and Minnesota.
    • Three human cases of bird flu have been tied to dairy cattle outbreaks.
    • Wyoming and Iowa both have laws that limit state oversight of raw milk sales to ‘informed end consumers’.
    • Recent research suggests the virus might also be spreading between cows in the respiratory tract.
  • Accuracy
    • FDA recommends states implement surveillance programs to test for the H5N1 virus on dairy farms selling raw milk.
    • Pasteurization kills dangerous organisms in milk and dairy products, making them safe to consume.
    • Aged cheese made from raw milk can still be sold over state lines, but it’s unclear if aging process will curb virus risk as effectively as for other pathogens.
    • Minnesota prohibits sales of raw milk from farms confirmed to have the virus.
    • Texas is conducting targeted testing of raw milk in regions with infected herds.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

70%

  • Unique Points
    • Louisiana was one of the few states with a full ban on raw milk sales before the bill passed.
    • The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention warns against consuming raw milk due to health risks.
    • Public comment emphasized talking points heard on conservative media during the legislative process.
    • ,avian flu has infected America's dairy cows and poses health risks for those consuming raw milk from infected cows.
    • The bill requires raw milk products to carry a label stating they're not for human consumption and haven't been pasteurized.
  • Accuracy
    • ] raw milk may contain harmful bacteria like listeria, typhoid fever, tuberculosis and diphtheria.[
    • Raw milk sales are already legal in the majority of states.
    • The bill requires raw milk products to carry a label stating they’re not for human consumption and haven’t been pasteurized.
  • Deception (30%)
    The author uses emotional manipulation by stating 'Reality check: Nearly all store-bought milk is pasteurized, a process that kills the bacteria that can lead to harmful diseases and illnesses like listeria, typhoid fever, tuberculosis and diphtheria,' implying that raw milk is dangerous without providing any evidence from peer-reviewed studies. The author also uses selective reporting by only mentioning the potential risks of raw milk without discussing its potential benefits. The author also states 'When the bill received overwhelming votes to pass the state House on May 31, members were heard mooing in the chambers,' which is a sensationalized statement that adds no value to the analysis.
    • Reality check: Nearly all store-bought milk is pasteurized, a process that kills the bacteria that can lead to harmful diseases and illnesses like listeria, typhoid fever, tuberculosis and diphtheria,
  • Fallacies (80%)
    The author makes an appeal to authority by quoting the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) about the health risks of consuming raw milk. However, she also quotes conservative media outlets making opposing arguments about the benefits of raw milk. This creates a dichotomous depiction, as the author presents two contrasting viewpoints without providing her own opinion or evidence to support either side.
    • The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention warns that consuming raw milk comes with big health risks, and that concern is growing as avian flu infects America’s dairy cows.
    • The Blaze published what it called an investigation on ‘the truth about raw milk the government doesn’t want you to know,’ calling raw milk ‘close to a perfect food’ in its headline.
  • Bias (90%)
    The author makes no direct assertions of bias in the article. However, she does mention several times that conservative media outlets like The Blaze and QAnon have been promoting raw milk as beneficial and safe. While the author does not express her own opinion on this matter, she is reporting on the fact that these outlets are pushing for raw milk sales despite health risks. This could be seen as a subtle implication of bias towards those who advocate for raw milk consumption, implying that they are ignoring or downplaying potential health hazards. Additionally, the author mentions avian flu and its potential impact on raw milk consumption without explicitly stating that it is a risk for humans, which could be seen as an omission of important information. This could potentially skew readers towards believing that raw milk is safer than it actually is.
    • The big picture: Commentators for conservative media like The Blaze, QAnon and Infowars have been sharing what they describe as the benefits of raw milk, according to an analysis from left-leaning Media Matters.
    • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication
    • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication

    83%

    • Unique Points
      • The latest diet trend on social media involves consuming raw, or unpasteurized, milk.
      • Mark McAfee, owner of Raw Farm USA, stated that people are seeking raw milk in large numbers.
      • An outbreak of bird flu affecting cow herds in the US has led to high levels of the virus in raw milk from infected cows.
      • Raw milk is milk that has not undergone pasteurization.
      • Pasteurization prevents diseases like listeriosis, typhoid fever, tuberculosis, diphtheria, Q fever and brucellosis.
      • From 1998 through 2018, there were 202 outbreaks linked to drinking raw milk that caused 2,645 illnesses and 228 hospitalizations.
    • Accuracy
      • People are seeking raw milk in large numbers.
      • Raw milk is healthier than pasteurized milk due to its supposedly higher nutrient content.
      • Business has been booming since the state legislature legalized raw milk sales last year.
    • Deception (100%)
      None Found At Time Of Publication
    • Fallacies (85%)
      The author makes an appeal to authority when quoting experts warning against consuming raw milk and the CDC's advice against it. The author also uses inflammatory rhetoric by comparing drinking raw milk to playing Russian roulette.
      • “Experts warn that this practice can be dangerous.”
      • “According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), from 1998 through 2018, there were 202 outbreaks linked to drinking raw milk. These outbreaks caused 2,645 illnesses and 228 hospitalizations.”
      • “I liken drinking raw milk to playing Russian roulette.”
    • Bias (80%)
      The author expresses a clear bias against consuming raw milk by using language that depicts those who do as following dangerous trends and playing Russian roulette. The author also quotes experts warning against the practice and provides statistics on illnesses caused by raw milk.
      • “I liken drinking raw milk to playing Russian roulette.”
        • “Is drinking raw milk dangerous? The FDA warns that raw milk, like raw meat, carries a higher risk of foodborne illness due to harmful germs like salmonella, E. coli, listeria and campylobacter.”
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication

        98%

        • Unique Points
          • H5N1 bird flu virus is spreading through dairy cattle in the US
          • Raw milk can carry high levels of H5N1 bird flu virus due to infection through udders
          • It is not yet known if people can get bird flu by drinking contaminated milk, but cats and dairy workers have been infected and died or fallen ill respectively
        • Accuracy
          • FDA does not allow raw milk sale across state lines but some states allow it for human consumption with varying requirements
        • Deception (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Fallacies (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Bias (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication