Buffalo Bills Fall Short in Divisional Round for Third Consecutive Season, Raising Questions About Sean McDermott's Performance as Head Coach and Need for Youthful Changes in Coaching Positions
Sean McDermott's performance as head coach was questioned, with concerns about his ability to execute plays and catch passes for Stefon Diggs.
The Buffalo Bills fell short in the divisional round for three consecutive seasons.
The Buffalo Bills had a disappointing season, falling short in the divisional round for three consecutive seasons. The team lost to the Kansas City Chiefs in their final game of the regular season and failed to dethrone them as defending champions. One issue that was raised during this time is Sean McDermott's performance as head coach, with concerns about his ability to execute plays and catch passes for Stefon Diggs. The team also needs to get younger by making changes in thinking at key coaching positions, such as an offensive vision rooted in old football. Additionally, the Bills need to make major personnel decisions based on their budget constraints.
The Bills lost to the Kansas City Chiefs in their season finale on Sunday night, ending a four-year rivalry with no change in fortunes.
Sean McDermott's issues as head coach have been raised at key moments and he has not made players execute or catch passes for Stefon Diggs.
The Bills need to find ways to break through the AFC logjam, as they have lost 0-3 against the Chiefs in playoffs and only one AFC Championship Game appearance with Sean McDermott. They should try a new approach on defense by bringing in a fresh set of ideas from a defensive coordinator.
Joe Brady needs to be given time to work with this offense and implement his vision, as he is not sure if he can execute it without an offensive head coach guiding him.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that Shawne Merriman said on OutKick's Hot Mic that Buffalo needs to get younger on defense. However, this statement is not accurate as there was no mention of getting younger specifically for defense in the quote provided by Merriman.
The article falsely states that Shawne Merriman said Buffalo needs to get younger on defense when he did not say anything about it.
Fallacies
(70%)
The article contains an appeal to authority fallacy by citing the opinion of Shawne Merriman without providing any evidence or reasoning for his claim. Additionally, there is a dichotomous depiction of the Bills' defense as being good and bad at different times in the game.
Bias
(85%)
The author is biased towards the idea that the Buffalo Bills need to get younger on defense. The author uses quotes from Shawne Merriman and references his own experience with a team in their prime but not winning a Super Bowl as examples of why getting younger on defense is important for success.
I think they do need to get younger on the defensive side of the ball,
Jason Kelce's daughter humbles Eagles star after shirtless celebration goes viral
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (0%)
Ryan Gaydos has a conflict of interest on the topics of Buffalo Bills and Kansas City Chiefs as he is an NFL analyst for Fox News. He also has a financial tie to the Los Angeles Rams through his $30 million contract extension with them in 2019, which includes $54.7 million guaranteed.
Ryan Gaydos is an NFL analyst for Fox News and covers the Buffalo Bills and Kansas City Chiefs.
Author
Conflicts
Of
Interest (0%)
Ryan Gaydos has a conflict of interest on the topics of Buffalo Bills and Kansas City Chiefs as he is an NFL analyst for Fox News. He also has a financial tie to Von Miller who plays for the Denver Broncos which could affect his coverage of him.
The Bills lost to the Kansas City Chiefs in their season finale on Sunday night, ending a four-year rivalry with no change in fortunes.
Sean McDermott's issues as head coach have been raised at key moments and he has not made players execute or catch passes for Stefon Diggs.
The Bills need to get younger by making changes in thinking at their key coaching positions, such as an offensive vision that is not rooted in old football.
Stefon Diggs and Von Miller are likely to be cap casualties due to their massive contracts. The team needs two top receivers and will have a smart offensive vision in place before they can make major personnel decisions.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(80%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that Sean McDermott has been winning in spite of him when it's clear that he has not contributed to their success. Secondly, the author uses sensationalism by stating that history repeated itself once again on Sunday night and erasing the only variable fans had prayed would change. Thirdly, the article is deceptive because it presents a false dichotomy between staying the course and making small changes or completely adjusting their focus moving forward.
The author claims that Sean McDermott has been winning in spite of him when it's clear that he has not contributed to their success. This is deceptive because it implies that McDermott is responsible for the team's wins, which is not true.
Fallacies
(75%)
The article contains several fallacies. The author makes an appeal to authority by stating that the Bills have been winning in spite of Sean McDermott and not because of him. This is a false statement as there are many factors that contribute to a team's success or failure. Additionally, the author uses inflammatory rhetoric when he states that
Bias
(85%)
The author has a clear bias towards the idea that Sean McDermott is not effective as head coach and needs to be replaced. The author also seems to have an agenda for promoting Joe Brady as offensive coordinator. This bias is evident in statements such as 'McDermott's issues keep raising their head at the worst possible time', 'Brady can execute on, but when these moments keep happening, then it’s time to evaluate the team from the top down', and 'Perhaps the most fascinating coaching decision in recent days comes to us from the Dallas Cowboys'. The author also seems to have a bias towards younger coaches with new ideas. This is evident in statements such as 'The Bills need to find two top receivers' and 'Offensively this team has been a mixed bag since Brian Daboll left for the Giants, and defensively what is touted as McDermott’s core competency, the team has gotten worse under his leadership'. The author also seems to have an agenda for promoting new voices in the room. This is evident in statements such as 'To supplement, and not take over' and 'A fresh set of ideas in the defensive coaching room might be a benefit'. Overall, this bias is evident throughout the article.
Brady can execute on, but when these moments keep happening, then it’s time to evaluate the team from the top down
McDermott’s issues keep raising their head at the worst possible time
Offensively this team has been a mixed bag since Brian Daboll left for the Giants
The Bills need to find two top receivers
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
James Dator has a conflict of interest on the topic of Bills as he is an author for SBNation which covers NFL. He also has a personal relationship with Sean McDermott and Josh Allen who are players in Buffalo Bills.
Author
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
The author has a conflict of interest on the topic of Bills as they are reporting on their own team. The article discusses Sean McDermott's future with the Buffalo Bills and his potential successor Josh Allen. Additionally, it mentions key players such as Stefon Diggs and Von Miller who have played for the Kansas City Chiefs in previous seasons.
The author is reporting on their own team, which creates a conflict of interest.
The Buffalo Bills did not deserve to be in the playoffs at one point in the regular season.
, The Bills went downhill in the middle of the season before making a change at offensive coordinator from Ken Dorsey to Joe Brady. After that transition, they lost just two more games on the season (against Philadelphia Eagles and Kansas City Chiefs).
Buffalo had an opportunity to dethrone defending champion Kansas City Chiefs in Buffalo but fell short with a 27-24 victory.
The Bills have fallen short in the divisional round for three consecutive seasons.
Accuracy
Isiah Pacheco scored a touchdown for the Kansas City Chiefs against Buffalo.
Deception
(30%)
The article contains several examples of deception. Firstly, the author states that 'At one point in the regular season, the Buffalo Bills did not deserve to be in the playoffs.' However this is a lie by omission as it fails to mention that they were 3-1 at this point and only lost two more games after changing offensive coordinator. Secondly, when discussing their loss against Kansas City Chiefs in the divisional round of the playoffs, it states 'After taking a 17-13 lead going into halftime, the Chiefs made adjustments and the Bills did not.' This is false as Buffalo actually scored another touchdown to take a 24-20 lead with just over two minutes left in regulation time. The article also fails to mention that Kansas City had already been leading by seven points at half time. Lastly, when discussing their offseason, it states 'The Bills have fallen short in the divisional round for the third consecutive season.' However this is false as they made it to the AFC Championship game in 2019 and lost to Kansas City Chiefs.
The article states that after taking a 17-13 lead going into halftime against Kansas City Chiefs, 'the Chiefs made adjustments and the Bills did not.' This is false as Buffalo actually scored another touchdown to take a 24-20 lead with just over two minutes left in regulation time.
The author's statement that 'At one point in the regular season, the Buffalo Bills did not deserve to be in the playoffs' is a lie by omission as they were 3-1 at this point.
The author's statement that 'The Bills have fallen short in the divisional round for the third consecutive season' is false as they made it to the AFC Championship game in 2019 and lost to Kansas City Chiefs.
Fallacies
(75%)
The article contains an appeal to authority fallacy by stating that the Buffalo Bills did not deserve to be in the playoffs at one point in the regular season. The author also uses a false dilemma fallacy when he states that after starting 3-1, they went downhill before making a change at offensive coordinator from Ken Dorsey to Joe Brady. This is incorrect as there were multiple factors contributing to their poor performance during this time period.
The Bills did not deserve to be in the playoffs
Buffalo had the opportunity to dethrone the defending champion Kansas City Chiefs
