Colombia's President Gustavo Petro announced intent to sever diplomatic ties with Israel over Gaza conflict
Colombia would join Belize and Bolivia as Western Hemisphere nations to suspend/sever ties with Israel
Israel strongly denied committing genocide in its war against Hamas in Gaza
Petro accused Israeli govt of causing deaths of girls, boys, and babies through bombs
Petro described Israeli government as 'genocidal'
Petro has background of opposition to Colombia's armed forces and was once a member of leftist M-19 guerrilla group
Colombia's President Gustavo Petro announced on May 1, 2024, that his government will sever diplomatic relations with Israel over the ongoing conflict in Gaza. Petro described the Israeli government as 'genocidal' during his announcement. This makes Colombia the second South American nation to break off relations with Israel after Bolivia did so in November 2023. The Colombian president made this statement at a May Day rally in Bogotá's central Plaza de Bolívar.
Petro accused Israel of causing the deaths of girls, boys, and babies through bombs. If Petro follows through with his threat, Colombia will join Belize and Bolivia as Western Hemisphere nations that have suspended or severed ties with Israel over the conflict in Gaza. Petro has a background of opposition to Colombia's armed forces and was once a member of the leftist M-19 guerrilla group.
Petro first threatened to break relations with Israel in March 2023 on social media, which was met with an Israeli Foreign Ministry response. Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) criticized Petro for being a 'terrorist sympathizer' and compared him to Venezuelan leader Hugo Chávez who severed his country's ties to Israel in 2009.
Petro referred to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as 'genocidal' in his speech. Colombia has historically been a close partner of Israel, with the South American country being the single largest overseas user of the Israeli-made Kfir jet fighter. However, Petro's government has taken a shift in international postures under his leadership.
Israel strongly denied committing genocide in its war against Hamas in Gaza. The Israeli Foreign Ministry responded to Petro's threat by saying that Israel 'will not give in to any pressures and threats.'
Colombia will break diplomatic relations with Israel on Thursday.
Colombian President Gustavo Petro called the Israeli government ‘genocidal.’
Israel has strongly denied committing genocide in its war against Hamas in Gaza.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(10%)
The author makes a clear assertion that Colombia will break diplomatic relations with Israel and calls the Israeli government genocidal. These are strong statements that require evidence to back them up. The article does not provide any peer-reviewed studies or facts to support these claims, making it an example of selective reporting and editorializing.
If Palestine dies, humanity dies, and we are not going to let it die.
Colombia is set to break diplomatic relations with Israel over its actions in Gaza.
he called its government genocidal.
Fallacies
(80%)
The author makes an inflammatory statement by calling the Israeli government 'genocidal' without providing any evidence or context to support this claim. This is an example of an appeal to emotion and a hasty generalization.
Colombian President Gustavo Petro called the Israeli government 'genocidal'.
Bias
(0%)
The author, Alex Leff, demonstrates clear political bias in this article by taking a side against Israel and referring to its government as 'genocidal'. He also quotes Colombian President Gustavo Petro making the same statement. The author does not provide any evidence or context to support this claim.
But Colombia’s leftist president is one of several Latin American leaders to take a strong vocal stand against Israel since its military campaign in Gaza
Colombia is set to break diplomatic relations with the state of Israel... calling its government 'genocidal'
'History will remember that Gustavo Petro decided to side with the most despicable monsters known to mankind'
If Palestine dies, humanity dies, and we are not going to let it die
Israel has strongly denied committing genocide in its war against Hamas in Gaza
Colombian President Gustavo Petro announced plans to sever diplomatic ties with Israel over Israel’s conduct in its war against Hamas in Gaza.
Petro made this announcement at a May Day rally in Bogotá’s central Plaza de Bolívar.
Israel is accused of causing the deaths of girls, boys, and babies through bombs by Petro.
Colombia will join Belize and Bolivia as Western Hemisphere nations that have suspended or severed ties with Israel over the conflict in Gaza if Petro follows through with his threat.
Petro has a background of opposition to Colombia’s armed forces and was once a member of the leftist M-19 guerrilla group.
Petro first threatened to break relations with Israel in March 2023 on social media, which was met with an Israeli Foreign Ministry response.
Senator Marco Rubio (Fla.) criticized Petro for being a ‘terrorist sympathizer’ and compared him to Venezuelan leader Hugo Chávez who severed his country’s ties to Israel.
Petro referred to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as ‘genocidal’ in his speech.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(0%)
The author, Rafael Bernal, makes several deceptive statements in this article. Firstly, he states that 'Colombian President Gustavo Petro plans to sever diplomatic ties with Israel over the Middle Eastern country’s conduct in its war against Hamas in Gaza.' However, he later admits that Petro's threat was made on social media and there has been no official announcement from the Colombian government. This is a lie by omission as Bernal failed to mention this important detail which would change the reader's perception of the situation. Secondly, Bernal states that 'Petro comes from a background of opposition to Colombia’s armed forces – as a teenager in the 1970s, he joined the leftist M-19 guerrilla group.' This statement is not relevant to Petro's current decision to sever diplomatic ties with Israel and is included for emotional manipulation and sensationalism. Lastly, Bernal states that 'Petro took the measure against Israel for having a government, for having a president, who is genocidal.' However, he later admits that Petro was likely referring to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. This statement is misleading as it implies that the entire Israeli government and population are genocidal when only Netanyahu holds this title.
The author states that 'Petro took the measure against Israel for having a government, for having a president, who is genocidal.' However, he later admits that Petro was likely referring to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
The author states that 'Petro comes from a background of opposition to Colombia’s armed forces – as a teenager in the 1970s, he joined the leftist M-19 guerrilla group.' This statement is not relevant to Petro's current decision to sever diplomatic ties with Israel.
The author states that 'Colombian President Gustavo Petro plans to sever diplomatic ties with Israel over the Middle Eastern country’s conduct in its war against Hamas in Gaza.' However, he later admits that Petro's threat was made on social media and there has been no official announcement from the Colombian government.
Fallacies
(85%)
The author, Rafael Bernal, makes an appeal to emotion when quoting Colombian President Gustavo Petro's statement about the 'girls, the boys, the babies who have died dismembered by the bombs.' This is an example of an appeal to pity fallacy. Additionally, there is a dichotomous depiction in Petro's statement where Israel is portrayed as solely responsible for these deaths without acknowledging any context or actions from other parties involved in the conflict.
> Colombian President Gustavo Petro said Wednesday he plans to sever diplomatic ties with Israel over the Middle Eastern country’s conduct in its war against Hamas in Gaza. … Petro panned Israel for ‘the girls, the boys, the babies who have died dismembered by the bombs.’
> In his speech Wednesday, Petro said he took the measure against Israel ‘for having a government, for having a president, who is genocidal.’
Bias
(0%)
The author, Rafael Bernal, demonstrates clear political bias against Israel by using emotionally charged language to describe the conflict in Gaza and labeling the Israeli government and prime minister as 'genocidal'. He also quotes Sen. Marco Rubio's statement that Petro is a 'terrorist sympathizer', which further indicates his bias.
Colombian President Gustavo Petro said Wednesday he plans to sever diplomatic ties with Israel over the Middle Eastern country’s conduct in its war against Hamas in Gaza. ... If Petro follows through with his threat, Colombia will join Belize and Bolivia as Western Hemisphere nations that have suspended or severed ties with Israel over the conflict in Gaza.
Petro’s threat to follow suit is a stark indicator of the shift in Colombia’s international postures under his government. ... In his speech Wednesday, Petro said he took the measure against Israel ‘for having a government, for having a president, who is genocidal.’
President Gustavo Petro described the Israeli government as ‘genocidal’ during his announcement.
Colombia is the second South American nation to break off relations with Israel after Bolivia.
Petro compared the events in Gaza to the Holocaust.
Accuracy
President Gustavo Petro described the Israeli government as 'genocidal'
Deception
(0%)
The author, Genevieve Glatsky, uses emotional manipulation and sensationalism by describing the Israeli government as 'genocidal' and stating that 'If Palestine dies, humanity dies.' She also selectively reports information by only mentioning deaths caused by Israeli forces without providing context or acknowledging violence from other sides. The author also makes a false comparison between events in Gaza and the Holocaust.
The times of genocide, of the extermination of an entire people cannot come before our eyes, before our passivity.
If Palestine dies, humanity dies.
Israel will continue to protect its citizens and will not yield to any pressure or threats.
Fallacies
(50%)
The author makes an inflammatory statement by calling the Israeli government 'genocidal' without providing evidence. This is a fallacy of name-calling or an appeal to emotion.
The times of genocide, of the extermination of an entire people cannot come before our eyes, before our passivity.
If Palestine dies, humanity dies.
Bias
(0%)
The author, Genevieve Glatsky, demonstrates clear political bias in this article by taking a position against Israel and supporting Colombia's decision to sever diplomatic ties. She also uses language that depicts the Israeli government as 'genocidal' and 'abominable monsters.'
Asking for food, more than 100 Palestinians were killed by Netanyahu.
Colombia will sever diplomatic ties with Israel over its prosecution of the war in Gaza, President Gustavo Petro announced in Bogotá on Wednesday, describing the Israeli government as ‘genocidal.’
Israel and Colombia always enjoyed warm ties. Even an antisemitic and hateful president will not change that.
Colombia’s president, Gustavo Petro, announced diplomatic relations with Israel will be severed over Israel’s actions in Gaza being described as ‘genocide’.
Petro called Israeli President ‘genocidal’.
Israel summoned Colombia’s ambassador in response to Petro’s comments.
Historically, Colombia had been one of Israel’s closest partners in Latin America. Both countries signed a free trade agreement in 2020.
Colombia uses Israeli-built warplanes and machine guns to fight drug cartels and rebel groups.
Accuracy
Colombia's president, Gustavo Petro, called Israeli President 'genocidal'
Israeli Foreign Minister Israel Katz accused Petro of siding with 'despicable monsters'
Petro previously came out in support of Brazil's president, Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, who also provoked Israel’s ire for describing the Gaza campaign as 'genocide'
Deception
(100%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Fallacies
(80%)
The author of the article does not make any explicit logical fallacies in their statements. However, they do quote Petro making the statement that 'Israel's siege of Gaza is genocide.' This statement can be considered an appeal to emotion and a dichotomous depiction, as it oversimplifies a complex situation into a black-and-white issue of 'genocide' or 'not genocide.' Additionally, the author quotes Israel Katz making an inflammatory statement about Petro. These statements do not detract significantly from the overall quality of the article and do not impact its score below 85.
]Colombia’s president has announced that his government will sever diplomatic relations with Israel, in the latest escalation of a furious row between the countries over the war in Gaza. ['Tomorrow, diplomatic relations with the state of Israel will be broken … for having a genocidal president,' Petro said, adding: 'If Palestine dies, humanity dies, and we are not going to let it die.']
Israel’s foreign minister, Israel Katz, quickly rebuked the Colombia leader’s comments, saying: ['History will remember that Gustavo Petro decided to side with the most despicable monsters known to mankind who burned babies, murdered children, raped women and kidnapped innocent civilians.']
Bias
(0%)
The author of this article is not identified, but the site is The Guardian which has a history of anti-Israel bias. The title and body of the article use the term 'genocide' to describe the situation in Gaza. While it may be true that some consider Israel's actions in Gaza to constitute genocide, this term is highly charged and can be seen as biased. Additionally, there are quotes from Colombian President Gustavo Petro and Israeli Foreign Minister Israel Katz that reflect their opposing viewpoints on the situation. However, these quotes do not necessarily reflect bias on the part of the author as they are simply reporting what was said. However, The Guardian's history of anti-Israel bias is a concern and lowers the overall score.
Colombia’s president has announced that his government will sever diplomatic relations with Israel, in the latest escalation of a furious row between the countries over the war in Gaza. Addressing a May Day rally in Bogotá on Wednesday, Gustavo Petro again described Israel’s siege of Gaza as ‘genocide’.
Israel’s foreign minister, Israel Katz, quickly rebuked the Colombia leader’s comments, saying: ‘History will remember that Gustavo Petro decided to side with the most despicable monsters known to mankind who burned babies, murdered children, raped women and kidnapped innocent civilians.’
