Neighborhood Residents Arrested in Columbia University Protests: Not 'Outside Agitators'

New York City, New York United States of America
Matthew Cavalletto, a local resident, was among those arrested and described the protesters as members of the community rather than outside agitators.
Protests at Columbia University this week resulted in over 100 arrests.
Three specific individuals were named: a middle-aged saxophonist, someone tending their sidewalk pepper patch, and a nanny who worked nearby.
Neighborhood Residents Arrested in Columbia University Protests: Not 'Outside Agitators'

U.S.WorldBusinessArtsLifestyleOpinionAudioGamesCookingWirecutterThe Athletic You have a preview view of this article while we are checking your access. When we have confirmed access, the full article content will load. “They struck me as members of the community, folks from the city, folks from our neighborhood,” said Matthew Cavalletto, who was among those arrested during protests at Columbia University this week. “And not some kind of foreign element that had snuck in to sap our city’s vitality.”Credit...Jeenah Moon for The New York Times May 4, 2024 One of the people arrested at Columbia University this week was a middle-aged saxophonist who headed up to the campus from his Hell’s Kitchen apartment after learning about the protests on social media.

Another was tending his sidewalk pepper patch a few blocks from the student demonstrations when he learned the police were moving in and, grabbing a metal dog bowl and a spoon to bang against it, rushed to the students’ aid.

A third had been active in other left-leaning protests across the city but also happened to work as a nanny nearby. She went to the university gates on Tuesday and linked arms with other protesters in an unsuccessful attempt to thwart the advancing officers, she said.

After pro-Palestinian demonstrators occupied a building on Columbia’s campus this week, demanding that the university end all financial ties with Israel, the New York Police Department moved in and arrested more than 100 people there. Mayor Eric Adams and other city leaders have accused so-called outside agitators — professional organizers with no ties to the university — of hijacking a peaceful student protest and spurring its participants to adopt ever more aggressive tactics.

“Professional, external actors are involved in these protests,” said Edward A. Caban, the New York City Police Commissioner. “They are not affiliated with either the institutions or campuses in question, and they are working to escalate the situation.”

A New York Times review of police records and interviews with dozens of people involved in the protest at Columbia found that a small handful of the nearly three dozen arrestees who lacked ties to the university had also participated in other protests around the country. One man who was taken into custody inside Hamilton Hall, the occupied campus building, had been charged with rioting and wearing a disguise to evade the police during a demonstration in California nearly a decade earlier.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe↓for all of The Times.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access.

Already a subscriber?↓Log in.

Want all of The Times?↓Subscribe. Advertisement



Confidence

85%

Doubts
  • It is unclear what specific tactics were adopted by protesters that led city leaders to label them as 'agitators'
  • The article states that a small handful of arrestees lacked ties to the university and had participated in other protests around the country, but it does not provide an exact number.

Sources

79%

  • Unique Points
    • James Carlson, a 40-year-old animal rights lawyer with no affiliation to Columbia University, was arrested inside Hamilton Hall for setting an Israeli flag on fire.
    • Lisa Fithian, a 63-year-old activist, was directing protesters on how to barricade doors and referred to two students as ‘assholes’.
  • Accuracy
    • Approximately 30% of those arrested at Hamilton Hall had no affiliation with the university.
  • Deception (50%)
    The article does not make any clear author opinions or editorializing. However, it does use emotional manipulation by describing the actions of the protesters as 'mob tactics' and 'intimidating students'. It also uses sensationalism by implying that outsiders played a significant role in the protests and occupation of Hamilton Hall without providing concrete evidence. The article also engages in selective reporting by focusing on the arrests of outsiders while downplaying the number of Columbia students arrested.
    • The larger number are going to be those people who are well meaning... But there are those who use those well meaning people for other purposes.
    • It's not always nefarious, but there are people who make a living off of protests.
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (95%)
    The article does not demonstrate a clear bias towards any particular political, religious, ideological or monetary position. The author's statements are focused on reporting facts about the individuals involved in the protests at Columbia University and their past arrest records. However, there is an example of language that could be perceived as biased when referring to some protesters as 'outsiders'. This term can be used to depict one side as extreme or unwelcome, but in this context it is being used to describe individuals who have no affiliation with the university. While this could potentially be seen as implying that these individuals are not welcome or that their involvement is unwarranted, it does not necessarily reflect a bias on the part of the author. The article also includes quotes from various perspectives, including those of students and activists who disagree with the characterization of outsiders as a threat to the student protest movement.
    • She was right in the middle of it, instructing them how to better set up the barricades.
      • Some student protesters think the narrative pushed by city and university officials – of dangerous outsiders co-opting the demonstrations – is fueled by ulterior motives.
        • The police swarmed the building late Tuesday and made a wave of other arrests at Columbia and the nearby City College of New York. A total of 46 people have been charged with trespassing in connection with the building’s occupation, according to the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office. At least 13 of them had no affiliation with the university, a Columbia spokesperson said.
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication

        96%

        • Unique Points
          • Protests at Columbia University involved local community members, not just external agitators.
          • Matthew Cavalletto, a protester arrested at Columbia University, described the protesters as ‘folks from the city’ and ‘not some kind of foreign element’.
          • A middle-aged saxophonist who lived in Hell’s Kitchen attended the protests after learning about them on social media.
          • Another protester tended his sidewalk pepper patch nearby and joined the protests when he learned of police presence.
          • A third protester, who worked as a nanny nearby, also participated in left-leaning protests and went to Columbia University to support the students.
        • Accuracy
          • Approximately 30% of those arrested at Hamilton Hall had no affiliation with the university.
          • At least 102 people had no ties to City College of New York out of the total arrests there (or 60%).
          • Mayor Eric Adams claimed there were no incidents of violence during the protests, which is a lie.
        • Deception (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Fallacies (95%)
          The authors use the dichotomous depiction fallacy by portraying the protesters as 'members of the community' and 'folks from our neighborhood' in contrast to 'external actors' or 'professional organizers'. This creates a false dichotomy between local and external protesters, implying that only local protesters are legitimate. However, this is not a valid distinction as both local and external protesters have the right to express their opinions and participate in peaceful protests.
          • “They struck me as members of the community, folks from the city, folks from our neighborhood,”
          • “Professional, external actors are involved in these protests,”
        • Bias (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication

        94%

        • Unique Points
          • Protesters disrupted the University of Michigan School of Music, Theatre & Dance commencement ceremony on Friday.
          • A person was heard yelling ‘get out’ as the protesters walked through the auditorium.
        • Accuracy
          • ]Protesters disrupted the University of Michigan School of Music, Theatre & Dance commencement ceremony on Friday.[
        • Deception (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Fallacies (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Bias (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication

        53%

        • Unique Points
          • Students knew they were likely to be arrested for being on campus despite the university-mandated shelter-in-place order.
          • Police threatened student journalists with arrest to minimize coverage.
          • Arrested students were taken to 1 Police Plaza where they were held in cells with inadequate facilities for women.
          • Mayor Eric Adams claimed there were no incidents of violence during the protests, which is a lie.
          • Columbia President Minouche Shafik thanked the NYPD for their ‘professionalism,’ which is also a lie.
          • Students were not violent or professional in their actions towards police.
          • Police removed women’s hijabs during bookings and refused to return them.
          • Women were forced to expose their genitalia to male officers in order to use the toilet.
        • Accuracy
          • Two dozen Columbia University students linked arms in front of Hamilton Hall and sang ‘Your people are my people, our struggles align.’
          • Students were seized by police and slammed to the ground despite having their hands up and not resisting.
        • Deception (30%)
          The article contains emotional manipulation through the use of phrases like 'broken yet mighty voices', 'hushed tones', and 'frail and cracking voices'. The author also uses selective reporting by only mentioning the actions of the police without providing any context or information about the protests or why they were taking place. Additionally, there are statements that imply facts without linking to peer-reviewed studies, such as 'College students are telling you exactly how they feel about the Israel-Hamas war. Listen.' and 'Gen Z supports Palestinians: Gen Z wants no part of Biden’s unceasing support of Israel as civilian deaths in Gaza mount'. These statements should be backed up with evidence to avoid deception.
          • Gen Z supports Palestinians: Gen Z wants no part of Biden’s unceasing support of Israel as civilian deaths in Gaza mount
          • We sang with hushed tones and breathed deeply as hundreds of New York police officers armed with flash grenades and pepper spray marched toward us like a military parade.
          • College students are telling you exactly how they feel about the Israel-Hamas war. Listen.
        • Fallacies (75%)
          The author uses inflammatory rhetoric by labeling the NYPD's actions as 'brutalizing students' and 'seizing a compliant student with her hands up and slamming her to the concrete ground'. She also makes an appeal to authority when she calls out Mayor Eric Adams for lying about there being no incidents of violence during the protests. Additionally, there is a dichotomous depiction of protesters as either 'heroes' or 'villains', which oversimplifies the complex nature of their actions.
          • This supposed professionalism is also a lie.
          • What is nonviolent and professional about seizing a compliant student with her hands up and slamming her to the concrete ground?
          • But make no mistake, we are not the heroes of this story – those honor belongs to those in Gaza; those whose families have been starved, whose cities have been bombed, whose children have been slaughtered; and those who did not have the privilege of choosing arrest or offering their bodies up as a public relations sacrifice.
          • We are calling to end the violence and genocide against our Palestinian brothers and sisters.
        • Bias (10%)
          The author expresses a clear bias towards the students protesting and against Columbia University and its president Minouche Shafik. The author uses language that depicts the police as brutal and unprofessional, while portraying the students as peaceful protesters. The author also makes assumptions about Mayor Eric Adams lying about incidents of violence.
          • At no point have the student organizers called for or promoted violence against our Jewish brothers and sisters. We are calling to end the violence and genocide against our Palestinian brothers and sisters.
            • The latter category belongs to Columbia and the broken system it refuses to heal.
              • This supposed professionalism is also a lie.
                • What is nonviolent and professional about seizing a compliant 120-pound student with her hands up and slamming her to the concrete ground?
                • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication

                95%

                • Unique Points
                  • A group of pro-Palestinian student protesters occupied a building at Columbia University for 18 hours.
                  • University administration declared an impasse and suspended protesting students.
                  • Students were ordered to stay in their dormitories or face arrest. Some continued yelling at police or were in tears.
                • Accuracy
                  • Approximately 30% of those arrested had no affiliation with the university.
                • Deception (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Fallacies (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Bias (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication