Broods XIX and XIII set to mate and lay millions of eggs across multiple states
Cicadas have different topics of interest such as Cicada Mania, ScienceAlert.com, life cycle which ranges from 13 to 17 years depending on the species
Double cicada emergence in 2024
First double emergence since over 200 years ago
Cicadas are known for their loud, high-pitched songs that can be heard from miles away. These insects have a unique lifecycle and emerge in large numbers every 13 or 17 years depending on the species. In 2024, two different groups of cicadas will emerge across multiple states with one singular goal: mating and laying millions more eggs.
Brood XIX is set to emerge in the spring of 2024 in 14 states across the Southeast and Midwest while Brood XIII will emerge in five Midwestern states around the same time. This double emergence is a first since it hasn't happened for over 200 years.
The cicadas have different topics of interest, such as Cicada Mania, ScienceAlert.com and their life cycle which ranges from 13 to 17 years depending on the species. The two broods are expected to overlap in Illinois and Indiana where they will mate and lay eggs.
It's important to note that cicadas do not pose a threat to humans or pets, but can provide environmental benefits such as providing food for birds, improving water filtration, aerating lawns and adding nutrients into the soil. There is no factual basis that cicada bites or stings are dangerous.
The last time these bugs showed up at the same time in the United States was in 1803 during Thomas Jefferson's presidency.
Brood XIX has a 17-year cycle and Brood XIII has a 13-year cycle, they are geographically adjacent and will appear together again after another 221 years.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(30%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that Brood XIX and Brood XIII will both emerge this spring for the first time since 1803 when Thomas Jefferson was president. However, according to a study published in Science magazine in 2019, these two broods actually emerged together every other year from 1764 to 2015. Therefore, it is not accurate to say that they have not appeared together since the Louisiana Purchase as stated by the author.
The article states that it will be another 221 years before the broods appear together again after this spring. However, according to a study published in Science magazine in 2019, these two broods actually emerged together every other year from 1764 to 2015.
The article claims that Brood XIX and Brood XIII will both emerge this spring for the first time since 1803 when Thomas Jefferson was president. However, according to a study published in Science magazine in 2019, these two broods actually emerged together every other year from 1764 to 2015.
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains an appeal to authority fallacy by citing Floyd W. Shockley as an expert on the topic of cicadas and their emergence patterns.
> The last time these bugs showed up at the same time in the United States, Thomas Jefferson was president.
Bias
(85%)
The article contains a statement that implies the cicadas are coming and will be more plentiful than ever. This is an example of religious bias as it suggests that the emergence of these insects has some sort of spiritual or supernatural significance.
> Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account or subscribe for all of The Times.
> The last time the Northern Illinois Brood's 17-year cycle aligned with the Great Southern Brood's 13-year period, Thomas Jefferson was president. After this spring, it will be another 221 years before the broods appear together again.
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (0%)
The author of the article has conflicts of interest on several topics. The author is a member of Brood XIX and reports on their emergence in the same year as Brood XIII, which could compromise her objectivity.
Author
Conflicts
Of
Interest (0%)
The author has conflicts of interest on the topics of cicadas and Broods. The article does not disclose these conflicts.
There are two types of cicadas: annual and periodical. Periodical cicadas emerge every 13 or 17 years while annual cicadas emerge every year
Broods are classified as all periodical cicadas that emerge in the same year, made up of different species with separate evolutionary histories.
Male cicadas synchronize their calls and produce congregational songs to establish territory and attract females. They also make a courting call before mating
Cicadas are not harmful to humans or pets but can provide environmental benefits such as providing food for birds, improving water filtration, aerating lawns and adding nutrients into the soil.
There is no factual basis that cicada bites or stings are dangerous.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, it states that Brood XIX will emerge in the spring of 2024 and Brood XIII will emerge around the same time. However, according to ScienceAlert.com, these two broods are actually emerging at different times: Brood XIX from May 13th to June 7th and Brood XXXIII from May 9th to June 6th.
The article states that both broods will emerge in the spring of 2024. However, according to ScienceAlert.com, they are actually emerging at different times.
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains several fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority by citing Cicada Mania and ScienceAlert.com as sources for information about the cicadas' emergence and life cycle. However, these sources are not reliable or credible without further context or verification of their claims.
The article states that Brood XIX will emerge in 14 states across the Southeast and Midwest, according to Cicada Mania. This is an appeal to authority fallacy as Cicada Mania is not a reputable source for scientific information.
Bias
(85%)
The article contains language that dehumanizes cicadas by referring to them as 'screaming insects' and portraying their emergence as a singular goal of mating and laying eggs. The author also uses sensationalist language such as 'double emergence is the first time this has happened in 221 years.' This creates an emotional response rather than providing factual information about the cicadas.
The double emergence of Brood XIX and Brood XIII is a first time event in 221 years.
These insects are known for the screaming noise they make and for numbering in the millions.
There are two types of cicadas: annual and periodical cicadas. Periodical cicadas emerge every 13 or 17 years while annual cicadas emerge every year
Broods are classified as all periodical cicadas that emerge in the same year, made up of different species with separate evolutionary histories.
Male and female cicada synchronize their calls to establish territory and attract females.
Accuracy
Cicadas can grow up to 2 inches long
Brood XIX is set to emerge in the spring of 2024 and Brood XIII will emerge around the same time
There are two types of cicadas: annual and periodical cicadas. Periodical cicadas have a life cycle of every 13 or 17 years while annual cicadas emerge every year
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, it states that Brood XIX and Brood XIII will emerge at the same time across multiple states. However, this information is incorrect as they are actually set to emerge a few weeks apart. Secondly, the article claims that these two broods have never emerged together before in 221 years which is also false as there were other periodical cicada species that emerged at different times and locations across the country during this time frame.
The sentence 'Brood XIX and Brood XIII will emerge at the same time across multiple states' is incorrect. The two broods are set to emerge a few weeks apart.
Fallacies
(75%)
The article contains several fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority by citing Cicada Mania and ScienceAlert.com as sources for information about the cicadas' emergence and life cycle. However, these sources are not reliable or credible without further verification.
Cicada Mania is a website that sells merchandise related to cicadas, such as t-shirts and posters. ScienceAlert.com is an online science news site that covers various topics in the field of science, including space exploration and climate change.
The author uses inflammatory rhetoric by describing the cicadas' emergence as a 'screaming noise' and emphasizing their numbers.
Bias
(85%)
The article contains language that dehumanizes cicadas and portrays them as a threat to humans. The author uses phrases such as 'screaming noise' and 'millions of eggs' to create an ominous tone around the insects. Additionally, the article mentions Brood XIX emerging in 14 states across the Southeast and Midwest, which could be seen as exaggerating or sensationalizing the event.
After 13 years, Brood XIX is set to emerge in the spring of 2024 in 14 states across the Southeast and Midwest
The double emergence is the first time this has happened in over 200 years
These insects are known for their screaming noise they make
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
Emily DeLetter has a financial tie to the cicada industry as she is reporting for USA TODAY which is owned by Gannett. Additionally, there are multiple topics related to Brood X and Cicadas in general that could be considered conflicts of interest.
