Israel is facing a crisis over its religious draft as the war in Gaza continues.
The Israeli Supreme Court has ruled that funding for ultra-Orthodox seminaries will be frozen unless their students serve in the military, which would sharply reduce the hit on freeing up reservists to work. This decision could have significant implications for Israel's political landscape and its relationship with other countries.
Israel is facing a crisis over its religious draft as the war in Gaza continues. The Israeli Supreme Court has ruled that funding for ultra-Orthodox seminaries will be frozen unless their students serve in the military, which would sharply reduce the hit on freeing up reservists to work. This decision could have significant implications for Israel's political landscape and its relationship with other countries.
It is not clear if this ruling will actually lead to a reduction in funding for ultra-Orthodox seminaries, or if it will be challenged by the government.
The High Court of Justice interim order on Thursday barred the government from funding the monthly stipends of at least some ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students.
Benny Gantz, a former IDF chief of staff and war cabinet Minister, welcomed the ruling in a tweet. He wrote that it is time for action to end unequal service in Israel.
Accuracy
Benny Gantz welcomed the ruling in a tweet. He wrote that it is time for action to end unequal service in Israel.
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that Gantz welcomes the High Court ruling to freeze funding to Haredi yeshivas when it is clear from his tweet and statement that he does not agree with this decision. Secondly, the author quotes MK Merav Michaeli as saying 'It's truly not against ultra-Orthodox and not against studying Torah,' but in reality, she has been a vocal opponent of Haredi exemptions from military service for years. Thirdly, the article presents Gantz's plan to see all Israelis serve in either the military or national service once they finish high school as an attempt to resolve the issue of unequal service when it is not clear that this would be a viable solution.
MK Merav Michaeli's quote about studying Torah being against nothing is presented as her stance on unequal service, when in reality she has been a vocal opponent of Haredi exemptions from military service for years.
The article presents Gantz's plan to see all Israelis serve in either the military or national service once they finish high school as an attempt to resolve the issue of unequal service but it is not clear that this would be a viable solution.
The author claims that Gantz welcomes the High Court ruling but his tweet and statement clearly show otherwise.
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains several examples of informal fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority by citing the High Court's ruling as if it is a definitive and objective truth. This is problematic because the court's decision may not be based on sound reasoning or evidence, but rather political considerations or personal biases. Additionally, the article contains several examples of inflammatory rhetoric, such as when Gantz calls Haredi students who are eligible for IDF enlistment
The High Court ruled the obvious today,
Bias
(85%)
The article contains a statement from Benny Gantz that implies the High Court ruling is not about religion or ideology but rather about serving in the military. However, this contradicts statements made by Haredi lawmakers who claim their right to study Torah and exemption from military service are religious rights.
The issue is not the High Court of Justice or the attorney general, who does her job faithfully,
The High Court of Justice interim order on Thursday barred the government from funding the monthly stipends of at least some ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students.
Benny Gantz welcomed the ruling in a tweet. He wrote that it is time for action to end unequal service in Israel.
The dispute over unequal service has been brewing in Israel for decades with successive governments repeatedly delaying attempts to legislate the issue after a 2012 High Court ruling that invalidated a previous arrangement to provide exemptions to yeshiva students. The court ruled on Thursday that after a government resolution from last year delaying the issue expires on March 31, the government will be barred from providing funding to ultra-Orthodox yeshivas.
Most Israelis see abstention from military service as unfair and a drain on economy.
Accuracy
Ultra-Orthodox Jews view religious study as fundamental to the preservation of Judaism and see it just as important to Israel's defense as the military.
Deception
(80%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, it states that the Israeli Supreme Court has ordered an end to state funding for ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students who do not serve in the army. However, this statement is misleading because the court only placed a temporary hold on subsidies until Monday and did not order an immediate end to them. Secondly, it quotes Gali Baharav-Miara stating that she does not see any legal basis for not moving forward with ultra-Orthodox conscriptions come Monday. However, this statement is also misleading because the court has already ruled that the exemptions are discriminatory and given Israel until June 30 to pass a new plan addressing these concerns. Finally, it quotes Aryeh Deri stating that mandatory conscription would threaten the way of life and commitment to upholding Jewish commandments for ultra-Orthodox students. However, this statement is misleading because many Jews believe that serving in the military is also a fulfillment of their religious obligations.
Gali Baharav-Miara stated that she does not see any legal basis for not moving forward with ultra-Orthodox conscriptions come Monday. However, this statement is also misleading because the court has already ruled that the exemptions are discriminatory and given Israel until June 30 to pass a new plan addressing these concerns.
The article states that the Israeli Supreme Court has ordered an end to state funding for ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students who do not serve in the army. However, this statement is misleading because it only places a temporary hold on subsidies until Monday and does not order an immediate end to them.
Aryeh Deri stated that mandatory conscription would threaten the way of life and commitment to upholding Jewish commandments for ultra-Orthodox students. However, this statement is misleading because many Jews believe that serving in the military is also a fulfillment of their religious obligations.
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains an appeal to authority fallacy by citing the Israeli Supreme Court's ruling without providing any evidence or context for their decision. Additionally, there is a dichotomous depiction of the ultra-Orthodox community as being exempt from military service and not contributing to Israel's war effort while other factions are expected to do so.
The Israeli Supreme Court on Thursday ordered an end to state funding for ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students who do not serve in the army
Most Jewish men in Israel are required to serve nearly three years in the military, along with years of reserve duty, while Jewish women must serve two mandatory years. But for decades, exemptions have existed for the ultra-Orthodox
Bias
(85%)
The article contains examples of religious bias. The author uses language that dehumanizes the ultra-Orthodox community by referring to them as 'ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students' who do not serve in the army. This is a clear example of how religion can be used to demonize and marginalize certain groups, which is highly biased.
The author uses language that dehumanizes the ultra-Orthodox community by referring to them as 'ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students' who do not serve in the army.
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
The author of the article has a conflict of interest with regards to the topic 'Israel' and 'Ultra-Orthodox'. The author is an ultra-orthodox woman who serves as a member in Israel's Supreme Court. This could compromise her ability to report on this topic objectively.
The article mentions that Gali Baharav-Miara has been involved in legal battles against the Israeli government regarding issues related to religion and military service.
The article mentions that Gali Baharav-Miara, the author of the article and a member of Israel's Supreme Court, is an ultra-orthodox woman who serves in the court. The author also discusses her personal experiences with serving in the army as an ultra-orthodox woman.
Netanyahu formed most right-wing and religious government in Israeli history
Haredi exemption violated constitutional mandate of equality according to liberal justices of high court
Most Israelis see abstention from military service as unfair and a drain on economy
If Haredim join the military, that would sharply reduce hit by freeing up reservists to work
Accuracy
Israel Supreme Court rules that freezes funding to ultra-Orthodox seminaries unless their students serve in the military
Netanyahu formed most right-wing and religious government in Israeli history, promising Haredim immunity from conscription
Deception
(80%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, it presents the issue of religious draft as a crisis for Netanyahu's government when in reality it has been an ongoing problem for years. The ultra-Orthodox parties have always had immunity from conscription and their refusal to serve in the military has been a burden on Israeli society for decades. Secondly, the article presents Benny Gantz as an opposition leader who is critical of Netanyahu's handling of this issue when in reality he was part of the government that formed just months ago. Thirdly, the article portrays Haredim as being against military service and their exemption from conscription as a violation of equality when in fact they believe religious study contributes far more to Israel's safety than military service. Finally, the article presents Netanyahu's request for more time to come up with a plan to start drafting Haredim as an attempt by him to delay this issue and avoid it altogether.
The article presents Haredim as being against military service and their exemption from conscription as a violation of equality when in reality they believe religious study contributes far more to Israel's safety than military service. This is a deceptive representation because it implies that the Haredim are opposed to serving in the military, which is not true.
The article portrays Benny Gantz as an opposition leader who is critical of Netanyahu's handling of the religious draft crisis when in reality he was part of the government that formed just months ago. This is a deceptive representation because it implies that Gantz has been consistently against Netanyahu on this issue, which is not true.
The article presents Netanyahu's request for more time as an attempt by him to delay this issue and avoid it altogether. This is a deceptive representation because it implies that Netanyahu has no intention of addressing this crisis and resolving the issue.
Fallacies
(80%)
The article contains an example of a false dilemma fallacy. The author presents the issue as if there are only two options: either the ultra-Orthodox parties join the military or they leave the government. This is not true because other options exist such as finding alternative ways to serve in the military that do not require conscription.
The article contains an example of a false dilemma fallacy.
Bias
(85%)
The authors demonstrate a bias against the ultra-Orthodox population in Israel by using negative language to describe them and their way of life. They imply that the ultra-Orthodox are a drain on the economy and security of Israel by not serving in the military, and they use phrases like 'cloistered life of poverty' to further demean this group.
A dramatic Israeli Supreme Court ruling that freezes funding to ultra-Orthodox seminaries unless their students serve in the military is forcing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government to contend with its survival as the war in Gaza deepens the country’s political divisions.
Haredim – some 13% of the Israeli population of almost 10 million and growing rapidly - live a cloistered life of poverty, prayer and study in large families. They believe religious study contributes far more to Israel’s safety than military service, and also fear their young men, if exposed to secular society, will leave the fold.
Many Israelis have long resented the exemption not only because Haredim don’t share the security burden, but also because their yeshivas receive government subsidies, permitting many of their men to study religious texts rather than work.
Most Read from Bloomberg Tesla’s $25,000 Car Means Tossing Out the 100-Year-Old Assembly Line Fed’s Preferred Inflation Metric Cools While Spending Rebounds Apple Plans New iPad Pro for May as Production Ramps Up Overseas Bankman-Fried Is Sentenced to 25 Years in Prison Over FTX Collapse UBS Banker’s Frustration Exposes Cracks in World of Climate Finance Ultra-Orthodox parties in the ruling coalition, who’d been assured that their decades-long immunity from conscription would be made permanent, were in a rage
Then came the Oct. 7 attack, when thousands of Hamas militants surged into Israel, killing 1,200, abducting 250 and triggering the call-up of hundreds of thousands of soldiers for what has turned into the longest war since the country’s independence 75 years ago.
The vow by Hamas – and similar militias like Hezbollah – to destroy Israel through more invasions has forced a rethinking of the country’s security doctrine, which has relied heavily on technology and intelligence over manpower.
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
The article discusses the religious draft in Israel and its impact on Netanyahu's coalition. The authors have a personal relationship with Netanyahu as they are both Israeli citizens. They also report on topics that are of interest to Ultra-Orthodox parties, which may compromise their ability to act objectively.
The article mentions the religious draft and its impact on Netanyahu's coalition.
The young men of the Haredim are exempt from mandatory military service due to their religion.
Israel has been at war with Hamas since October 7, and this has put it on a war footing for nearly six months with the prospect of more to come.
Ultra-Orthodox Jews view religious study as fundamental to the preservation of Judaism and see it just as important to Israel's defense as the military.
The exemption issue has been a contentious one in Israeli society since its founding, with many Ultra-Orthodox Jews opposed to mandatory military service on religious grounds.
Accuracy
Netanyahu relies on two Ultra-Orthodox parties, Shas and United Torah Judaism, to maintain a governing coalition.
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, it presents the Israeli Supreme Court's decision as a blow to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu when in fact it was a long-awaited and necessary step towards equality for all Israelis. The court ruled that the government could no longer transfer funds to yeshivas whose students did not receive legitimate deferments, which is an important victory for those who believe in equal rights and opportunities for everyone. Secondly, the article presents Ultra-Orthodox Jews as privileged and exempt from military service when in fact they have been fighting wars alongside other Israelis since the country's founding. The exemption was never enshrined in a law that the Supreme Court views as equitable, and it has only been upheld by patchwork government mandates. Finally, the article presents Ultra-Orthodox Jews as viewing religious study as more important than military service when in fact many of them have served in the army and see both activities as equally important to Israel's defense.
The Israeli Supreme Court on Thursday ordered the government to stop funding religious schools whose students defy mandatory military service, posing one of the most serious threats to date for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
Ultra-Orthodox Jews have long held a privileged position in Israel, with their schools receiving generous government subsidies. The young men of the Haredim are in all practical terms exempt from mandatory military services
Fallacies
(100%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Bias
(85%)
The article is biased towards the Israeli Supreme Court's decision to stop funding religious schools that defy enlistment. The author uses language such as 'blow to Netanyahu', 'threatens date for prime minister', and 'in all practical terms exempt from mandatory military services'. These statements suggest a negative view of Netanyahu and the Ultra-Orthodox community, which is not supported by evidence in the article. Additionally, the author uses quotes from Shas party leader Ariyeh Deri to further their own bias against the Supreme Court's decision.
The judges of the High Court of Justice want to saw off the branch of existence of the Jewish people,
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
The authors of the article have a conflict of interest with Israeli Supreme Court as they are reporting on an order issued by it. They also have a personal relationship with Benjamin Netanyahu and Ariyeh Deri who were mentioned in the article.
Mick Krever is known for his coverage of Israel's political scene, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) will then be required to send conscription notices to roughly 66,000 ultra-Orthodox men who had been previously exempted by a law carving out special privileges for students at religious academies.
Benny Gantz, a more centrist rival to Netanyahu who would likely differ on some critical issues, including the political future of Gaza and the possibility of a Palestinian state.
Accuracy
The conscription issue splits Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government apart.
If he permits mass conscription of yeshiva students, they will abandon him. If he gives the ultra-Orthodox what they want, he will run afoul of key members of his own right-wing Likud party.
Deception
(30%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author presents this as a crisis that could bring down Benjamin Netanyahu when it's not clear if it will actually do so. The conscription issue may cause political turmoil but there's no guarantee that it will lead to Netanyahu being ousted from power or even trigger new elections.
The author presents this as a crisis that could bring down Benjamin Netanyahu when it's not clear if it will actually do so.
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains several fallacies. The first is an appeal to authority when it states that the conscription issue splits Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government apart at the seams. This statement implies that Netanyahu has no control over his own government and is not responsible for their actions, which is a false premise.
The conscription issue splits Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government apart at the seams.
Bias
(85%)
The author has a clear bias towards the ultra-orthodox parties and their position on conscription. The author portrays them as being in an impossible situation where they will either abandon Netanyahu or run afoul of key members of his own right-wing Likud party. This is not a balanced view, as it ignores other perspectives that may exist within the ultra-orthodox community and their motivations for opposing conscription.
The author portrays the ultra-Orthodox parties as being in an impossible situation where they will either abandon Netanyahu or run afoul of key members of his own right-wing Likud party.
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
Zack Beauchamp has a conflict of interest on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and Benjamin Netanyahu as he is an ultra-Orthodox Jew who may have personal ties to these topics. He also has professional affiliations with Likud party and IDF which could compromise his ability to report objectively.
The article discusses Zack Beauchamp's personal experience with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and his views on Benjamin Netanyahu.
Zack Beauchamp mentions in the article that he grew up attending a yeshiva, an Orthodox Jewish school, and attended Harvard University's Hillel Foundation. He also states that as a child of Holocaust survivors, he has always been deeply interested in Israel.
:no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25360610/2059118672.jpg)
:no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25360609/2087327825.jpg)
