New Evidence of Israeli-American Hostages Held by Hamas: Criticisms and Hope in Propaganda Videos

Gaza, Gaza Strip Palestine, State of
Goldberg-Polin criticized Israeli PM Netanyahu in video
Hamas serious about releasing hostages if Israel agrees to ceasefire
Israeli-Americans Hersh Goldberg-Polin and Keith Siegel shown alive in Hamas propaganda videos
Negotiations for ceasefire and hostage exchange ongoing
Residents of Gaza growing critical of Hamas as conflict drags on
Siegel and Miran expressed hope for deal to return home in video
New Evidence of Israeli-American Hostages Held by Hamas: Criticisms and Hope in Propaganda Videos

Editor's Note: This article contains graphic descriptions and images.

Two Israeli-American hostages, Hersh Goldberg-Polin and Keith Siegel, have been shown alive in separate propaganda videos released by Hamas. The videos provide the first evidence that both men are still being held captive after more than 200 days in Gaza.

Hersh Goldberg-Polin, who is missing his lower arm, was captured during the October 7 attack on Israel and taken to Gaza. In a video published on April 24, he criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for abandoning the hostages still in Gaza.

Keith Siegel and Omri Miran were also kidnapped from Kibbutz Kfar Aza during the same attack. Aviva Siegel, Keith's wife, was released during a ceasefire. In a video published on April 27, Keith and Omri expressed hope for a deal to return home.

Both videos were described as propaganda by Israeli officials and are likely filmed under duress.

As negotiations for a ceasefire and hostage exchange continue, Hamas' political arm has stated that it is 'serious' about releasing the hostages if Israel agrees to a ceasefire. However, Hamas is also attempting to prevent a full-scale invasion of Rafah, where an estimated 1.4 million people are seeking refuge.

Meanwhile, residents of Gaza are growing increasingly critical of Hamas as the war drags on and hopes for a ceasefire fade. More than six months into the conflict, Palestinians in Gaza blame Hamas for their suffering and the destruction of their territory.



Confidence

85%

Doubts
  • It is unclear if the videos were filmed under duress or if the men's statements are genuine
  • The status of Omri Miran, who was also kidnapped with Siegel, is unknown

Sources

98%

  • Unique Points
    • Hamas has released a propaganda video showing American-Israeli hostage Keith Siegel is still alive after more than 200 days in captivity.
    • Siegel and Israeli hostage Omri Miran appear gaunt and emotionally distressed in the video.
    • They identify themselves as hostages and express hope for a deal to return home.
    • Siegel was kidnapped on October 7, 2021, from Kibbutz Kfar Aza with his wife Aviva. Aviva was released during a ceasefire.
    • The video includes details suggesting it was filmed recently and mentions the Passover holiday falling between April 22 and April 30.
    • Siegel has been held captive for approximately 204 days as of Saturday, while the hostages were kidnapped on the 204th day.
  • Accuracy
    • Negotiations for a ceasefire and hostage exchange are ongoing between Hamas and Israel.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

87%

  • Unique Points
    • More than six months into the war in Gaza and with dimming hopes for a cease-fire deal, Palestinians there are growing more critical of Hamas.
  • Accuracy
    • ]More than six months into the war in Gaza and with dimming hopes for a cease-fire deal, Palestinians there are growing more critical of Hamas.[
    • Hamas has released a propaganda video showing American-Israeli hostage Keith Siegel is still alive after more than 200 days in captivity.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (75%)
    The article contains several examples of inflammatory rhetoric and appeals to authority. It also presents dichotomous depictions of Hamas, portraying them as both the oppressors and the protectors of the Palestinian people. However, there are no formal fallacies present in the text.
    • “By any means, we want the war to stop, whatever it takes.”
    • “We can’t live like this anymore.”
    • Hamas has never really tolerated dissent, and it arrested, jailed and beat activists who spoke out against its rule.
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

98%

  • Unique Points
    • Hamas published a video showing Hersh Goldberg-Polin, an Israeli-American hostage, alive
    • Hersh Goldberg-Polin was seized during the Oct. 7 attack on Israel and taken to Gaza
    • Hersh Goldberg-Polin is missing his lower arm which was blown off during the attack
  • Accuracy
    • Hersh Goldberg-Polin is one of 133 Israeli hostages still in captivity after more than 100 were released last year
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

100%

  • Unique Points
    • Hamas released a video of Israeli-American hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin on October 7, 2021, providing the first proof that he survived his injuries during his capture on October 7, 2021.
    • Goldberg-Polin was injured while helping to throw grenades out during Hamas attack, before his arm was blown off from the elbow down.
    • He is shown in the video with part of his left arm missing several inches above the hand.
    • Goldberg-Polin criticizes Israeli government led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the video.
  • Accuracy
    No Contradictions at Time Of Publication
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication