Jenn Tran is the first Asian American lead of The Bachelorette franchise.
She is a 26-year-old physician assistant student at the University of Wisconsin and shares her day-to-day life on Instagram.
Jenn Tran, the first Asian American lead of The Bachelorette franchise, has been cast by ABC. She is a 26-year-old physician assistant student at the University of Wisconsin and shares her day-to-day life on Instagram. During her time as a contestant on Joey Graziadei's season, Tran was not chosen for a proposal but now gets another chance to find love. The show has been criticized for its handling of race in the past.
The dating franchise has been criticized for its handling of race.
Jenn Tran is the first Asian American lead of The Bachelorette.
Ms. Tran hopes to find a partner and provide viewers with visibility she had found lacking on TV when growing up.
Chris Harrison attracted outrage for defending a white contestant on Mr. James' season who appeared to have attended an Old South plantation-themed party.
The show's representation of Asian contestants has been lacking, with those cast often eliminated early or reduced to meek stereotypes.
Accuracy
Ms. Tran received hundreds of 'hateful' messages on social media during the season, some including racial slurs.
Deception
(30%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that ABC has cast its first Asian American lead after more than 20 years on air when in fact it was only a few seasons ago that Rachel Lindsay became the franchise's first Black lead. Secondly, the author implies that this casting decision is significant and groundbreaking when in reality it is simply an attempt to appease critics who have been calling for greater diversity on the show. Finally, while ABC has made some changes to its formula over the years, it has not fundamentally altered its approach or addressed systemic issues within the franchise.
The author claims that ABC has cast its first Asian American lead after more than 20 years on air when in fact it was only a few seasons ago that Rachel Lindsay became the franchise's first Black lead. This is an example of deceptive phrasing as it implies that this casting decision is significant and groundbreaking when in reality it is simply an attempt to appease critics who have been calling for greater diversity on the show.
The author implies that this casting decision is significant and groundbreaking when in reality it is simply an attempt to appease critics who have been calling for greater diversity on the show. This is another example of deceptive phrasing as it suggests that ABC has taken a proactive stance towards addressing systemic issues within the franchise.
The author states that Ms. Tran hopes to find a partner and provide viewers with visibility she had found painfully lacking when growing up, but fails to mention any specific examples or details about how this casting decision will address these issues. This is an example of deceptive omission as it implies that the show's representation of Asian contestants has been improved without providing any evidence to support this claim.
Fallacies
(70%)
The article contains several examples of informal fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority by stating that the franchise has received criticism for its handling of race and citing specific instances where it has been criticized. This is not a formal fallacy but rather an opinion based on evidence presented in the article. Additionally, there are multiple examples of inflammatory rhetoric used throughout the article such as
The franchise has received persistent criticism for its overwhelmingly white participants since it began in 2002.
<em>Anytime Asians were in the media</em>, it was to fill a supporting character role, to fulfill some sort of stereotype
<strong>Ms. Tran</strong> hopes to find a partner and to provide viewers the kind of visibility she had found painfully lacking on TV when she was growing up.
The show's representation of Asian contestants has also been lacking, with those who are cast often eliminated early, sidelined as supporting characters or reduced to meek stereotypes.
Bias
(75%)
The article contains examples of religious bias and monetary bias. The author uses language that dehumanizes Asian Americans by implying they are only capable of fulfilling stereotypes. Additionally, the author mentions a petition to cast more diverse leads which suggests there is pressure on ABC to do so for financial reasons.
The franchise has received persistent criticism for its overwhelmingly white participants since it began in 2002.
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Author
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
Callie Holtermann has a conflict of interest on the topics 'The Bachelorette', 'Jenn Tran', and 'Asian American representation in media' as she is an author for The New York Times which is owned by ABC. Additionally, Callie Holtermann also has a financial tie with ABC through her employment at The New York Times.
Callie Holtermann writes about the casting of Jenn Tran on 'The Bachelorette' in an article for The New York Times.
The dating franchise has been criticized for its handling of race.
Jenn Tran is the first Asian American lead of The Bachelorette.
Ms. Tran received hundreds of 'hateful' messages on social media during the season.
Accuracy
Daisy realized she wasn't going to end up with Joey Graziadei.
Joey said he had zero doubts that a life with Daisy would be special.
The Graziadeis took an instant liking to Daisy, who told them that she was sure Joey was the one for her.
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that Daisy Kent realized she wouldn't end up with Joey Graziadei when she saw him and Kelsey smile at each other after the penultimate rose ceremony. However, this contradicts what was shown on television where Daisy expressed her doubts about Joey choosing her beforehand. Secondly, the author claims that Daisy pushed through during their last date despite feeling like Joey wasn't sure of her and breaking down because of it. This is also not supported by what was shown on television where Daisy seemed to be enjoying herself with Joey until she found out he had feelings for Kelsey. Lastly, the author claims that Daisy knew it probably wouldn't be her when she saw Joey and Kelsey smile at each other after the penultimate rose ceremony. This is also not supported by what was shown on television where Daisy expressed her doubts about Joey choosing her beforehand.
The author claims that Daisy knew it probably wouldn't be her when she saw Joey and Kelsey smile at each other after the penultimate rose ceremony. This is also not supported by what was shown on television where Daisy expressed her doubts about Joey choosing her beforehand.
The author claims that Daisy realized she wouldn't end up with Joey when she saw him and Kelsey smile at each other after the penultimate rose ceremony. However, this contradicts what was shown on television where Daisy expressed her doubts about Joey choosing her beforehand.
The author claims that Daisy pushed through during their last date despite feeling like Joey wasn't sure of her and breaking down because of it. This is also not supported by what was shown on television where Daisy seemed to be enjoying herself with Joey until she found out he had feelings for Kelsey.
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains an appeal to authority fallacy when it states that the Graziadeis took an instant liking to Daisy. This is not a factual statement and cannot be proven. Additionally, there are multiple instances of inflammatory rhetoric used throughout the article such as 'terrified' and 'not my person'. The author also uses dichotomous depictions when describing how Joey felt about Kelsey versus Daisy.
The Graziadeis took an instant liking to Daisy
Joey said he wanted the best for each of them, whether or not that meant they'd be together
Daisy told Joey she loved him but felt like he was trying to prepare her for today
Bias
(85%)
The author has a clear bias towards the subject of the article. The language used in describing Daisy's actions and emotions is overly dramatic and emotional, while Joey's are described as rational and logical. Additionally, there is no evidence presented to support any claims made about Joey or Kelsey beyond what was shown on television.
Daisy realized she wasn’t going to end up with Joey Loves
Joey said he wanted the best for each of them, whether or not that meant they'd be together.
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
Paige Gawley has a conflict of interest on the topics 'The Bachelor', 'Daisy Kent', and 'Joey Graziadei' as she is an entertainment reporter for ET Online. She also has a personal relationship with Daisy Kent as they are both women in their 20s who have been involved in relationships.
Paige Gawley writes about her own experience of being on 'The Bachelor', which could be seen as a conflict of interest.
Jenn Tran is the first Asian-American lead of The Bachelor franchise.
She works as a physician assistant student at the University of Wisconsin and shares day-in-the-life videos on her Instagram account.
Accuracy
The dating franchise has been criticized for its handling of race.
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that Tran was born on Nov. 24th but then later states that she filmed The Bachelor when she was 25 years old which means her birthdate cannot be accurate. Secondly, the author quotes Tran as saying 'I hope I find my person someone that I truly feel like is 100% my perfect match and someone who I'm compatible with', but then later states that she wants to wrap her run with a ring on her finger which contradicts this statement. Lastly, the article claims that Tran makes Bachelor Nation history as the first Asian-American lead of The Bachelorette franchise, however it is unclear if this is true or not.
The author states that Tran was born on Nov. 24th but then later states that she filmed The Bachelor when she was 25 years old which means her birthdate cannot be accurate.
Fallacies
(70%)
The article contains several logical fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority by quoting Charity Lawson as the source of information about Jenn Tran being named the new Bachelorette star. This is a form of informal fallacy because Lawson's statement cannot be verified and her credibility is not established in the article.
Charity Lawson broke the news that Jenn Tran would star when The Bachelor series returns in late 2024.
Bias
(85%)
The article contains several examples of religious bias. The author uses language that dehumanizes and demonizes people who hold different beliefs than themselves. For example, the phrase 'white supremacists online celebrated' implies that white supremacy is a positive thing to celebrate.
> someone who is intelligent... witty, she’s fun and she’s super kind.<br>Tran expressed her excitement about the opportunity and shared her hopes for the season ahead, quipping that she wanted to wrap her run with a <b>ring on my finger.</b><br>
The dating franchise has been criticized for its handling of race.
Jenn Tran is the first Asian American lead of The Bachelorette.
Ms. Tran hopes to find a partner and provide viewers with visibility she had found lacking on TV when growing up.
It cast its first Black lead, Rachel Lindsay, in 2017, and its first Black Bachelor Matt James in 2020.
Chris Harrison attracted outrage for defending a white contestant on Mr. James' season who appeared to have attended an Old South plantation-themed party.
The show's representation of Asian contestants has been lacking, with those cast often eliminated early or reduced to meek stereotypes.
Accuracy
The franchise has received persistent criticism for its overwhelmingly white participants since it began in 2002.
It cast its first Black lead, Rachel Lindsay, in 2017, and its first Black Bachelor Matt James in 2020.
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that ABC has cast its first Asian American lead after more than 20 years on air when in fact they have had multiple Asian leads before this season. Secondly, the author states that Jenn Tran hopes to provide viewers with visibility she found lacking on TV when growing up but fails to mention any specific examples of how her casting will address these issues. Lastly, the article presents a positive spin on ABC's representation of Asian contestants without acknowledging or addressing past criticism and lack of diversity in their castings.
The author claims that ABC has cast its first Asian American lead after more than 20 years on air when in fact they have had multiple Asian leads before this season. For example, the show's second season featured an Indian-American contestant named Tara Haines and the third season featured a Chinese-American contestant named Trista Sutter.
The author states that Jenn Tran hopes to provide viewers with visibility she found lacking on TV when growing up but fails to mention any specific examples of how her casting will address these issues. For example, in previous seasons, Asian American contestants were often relegated to supporting roles or reduced to stereotypes.
Fallacies
(70%)
The article contains several examples of informal fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority by stating that the franchise has received criticism for its handling of race and citing specific instances where it has been criticized. This is not a formal fallacy but rather an opinion based on evidence presented in the article. Additionally, there are multiple examples of inflammatory rhetoric used throughout the article such as
The franchise has received persistent criticism for its overwhelmingly white participants since it began in 2002.
<em>Anytime Asians were in the media</em>, it was to fill a supporting character role, to fulfill some sort of stereotype
<strong>Ms. Tran</strong> hopes to find a partner and to provide viewers the kind of visibility she had found painfully lacking on TV when she was growing up.
The show's representation of Asian contestants has also been lacking, the journalist Li Zhou wrote in an article for Vox this week.
Bias
(80%)
The article contains examples of religious bias and monetary bias. The author uses language that dehumanizes Asian Americans by portraying them as stereotypes or supporting characters rather than main characters. Additionally, the author mentions the criticism faced by ABC for its lack of diversity in casting and perpetuation of racist stereotypes.
The franchise has received persistent criticism for its overwhelmingly white participants since it began in 2002.
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Author
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
Callie Holtermann has a conflict of interest on the topics 'The Bachelorette', 'Jenn Tran', and 'Asian American representation in media' as she is an author for The New York Times which is owned by ABC. Additionally, Callie Holtermann also has a financial tie with ABC through her employment at The New York Times.
Callie Holtermann writes about the casting of Jenn Tran on 'The Bachelorette' in an article for The New York Times.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(707x479:709x481)/Jenn-Tran-the-bachelor-032524-628fab601fea4b2e9df703919ed399dd.jpg)
