Bill would make it illegal to sell tobacco products to those born after 2009
Legislation includes measures to crack down on youth vaping
Opponents argue it limits personal freedoms and risks creating black market
Rishi Sunak's tobacco and vape bill aims to create UK's first smoke-free generation
Rishi Sunak's tobacco and vapes bill, announced at the Conservative party conference last year, aims to create the UK's first smoke-free generation by making it illegal to sell tobacco products to anyone born after January 1, 2009. The legislation also includes measures to crack down on youth vaping such as banning the sale of cheap disposable vapes and restricting their flavors. The bill passed its first hurdle in Parliament despite opposition from some Conservative Party members who criticized it as a limitation of personal freedoms and an unrealistic enforcement nightmare. The plan was inspired by similar policies proposed by New Zealand but faced criticism for potentially creating a black market.
The legislation, which must go through a few more steps before it becomes law, would raise the legal age for tobacco purchase each year until it is eventually illegal for the whole population. Smoking kills about 80,000 people in the UK every year and remains the number one preventable cause of death. Creating a smoke-free generation could prevent over 470,00 cases of heart disease, stroke, lung cancer and other diseases by the end of the century.
Prime Minister Sunak argued that most smokers start in their teens and that this legislation is necessary to protect future generations from the harmful effects of smoking. However, opponents argue that it goes against conservative values by limiting personal freedoms and risks creating a black market. Some also criticized the move as treating future generations like children.
The number of tobacco retailers in the UK has declined significantly over the years due to higher taxes and education campaigns, but about 6.4 million people in the country still smoke, or about 13% of the population. Authorities say that smoking causes some 80,000 deaths a year in the UK and is responsible for lost productivity worth £17bn annually.
Britain passed a bill on Tuesday banning the sale of cigarettes to anyone born in 2009 or later.
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak led the fight for this legislation, arguing that smoking kills tens of thousands of people each year and most smokers start in their teens.
Accuracy
The legislation aims to create a ‘smoke-free generation.’
Smoking rates among teens remain high, with more than 12 percent of 16- and 17-year-olds smoking in England.
Deception
(100%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Fallacies
(100%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Bias
(95%)
The author expresses a clear bias towards the anti-smoking legislation and the benefits of it, while also depicting those opposing it as being against people's freedom. The author uses language such as 'nanny state', 'health police', and 'hugely problematic' to describe those who oppose the legislation.
As in much of the world, smoking rates have declined in Britain (as vaping has increased). But still, about 1 in 8 people in Britain smoked last year – some 6.4 million people.
Business secretary Kemi Badenoch was the first cabinet member to say she would be voting against her boss. She said she objected to an approach where people born a day apart will have permanently different rights and put the burden of enforcement on private businesses.
But while his signature health legislation passed 383-67, with the support of Labour lawmakers, it has fomented revolt within his own Conservative Party and fed a debate about what Britain’s conservatives should stand for.
Former prime minister Boris Johnson – who has occupied himself with a newspaper column and speaking gigs since being pressured out of Parliament – pointed to the tobacco ban as a prime example of what’s wrong with his Conservative Party right now.
Instead, the country’s new government in February announced that it will scrap the rules to help pay for tax cuts – and because, in its estimation, the ban could create an illegal black market that would be hard to control.
She denounced health police.,
Sunak’s legislation was inspired by New Zealand, which last year passed the toughest anti-tobacco laws in the world, intended to ban sales to those born after Jan. 1, 2009, as well as cut nicotine content and slash the number of tobacco retailers.
, Truss called the ban emblematic of a technocratic establishment in this country that wants to limit people’s freedom.,
We’re banning cigars. What is the point of banning – the party of Winston Churchill wants to ban cigars! Donnez-moi un break, as they say in Quebec. It’s just mad,
When I look at some of the things we are doing now, or that are being done in the name of conservatism, I think they’re absolutely nuts.,
Rishi Sunak’s tobacco and vapes bill aims to create the UK’s first smoke-free generation.
The legislation will make it illegal to sell tobacco products to anyone born after 1 January 2009.
Smoking kills about 80,000 people a year in the UK.
Creating a smoke-free generation could prevent more than 470,000 cases of heart disease, stroke, lung cancer, and other diseases by the end of the century.
Some Conservative Party members, including former prime ministers Boris Johnson and Liz Truss, say the plans go against conservative values by limiting personal freedoms.
Opponents argue the move risks creating a black market and treating future generations like children.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(30%)
The article contains selective reporting as it only reports details that support the author's position of Conservative Party members opposing the smoking ban. It also contains emotional manipulation through quotes from Conservative Party members expressing their opposition and fear of a 'nanny state'. The article does not disclose any sources.
Prominent voices within the Conservative Party, including two of Sunak’s predecessors, Boris Johnson and Liz Truss, said the plans went against conservative values by limiting people’s personal freedoms.
Conservative lawmakers were granted a free vote, meaning they could vote with their personal conscience rather than follow the official party line.
Other high-profile Tories, including business secretary Kemi Badenoch, a Cabinet minister, also opposed the bill.
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains a few informal fallacies and appeals to authority. It does not contain any formal logical fallacies.
. . . the plans went against conservative values by limiting people's personal freedoms.
Smoking itself would not be subject to fines. Older smokers would be allowed to continue to buy tobacco until they quit, or die.
Chris Whitty, chief medical officer for England, who served under Johnson during the pandemic, says his old boss has got it wrong.
Bias
(90%)
The article includes several statements from Conservative Party members expressing their opposition to the proposed smoking ban, framing it as an infringement on personal freedoms. The author does not challenge or provide counterarguments to these statements.
Johnson told a gathering in Canada last week that the proposed ban was ‘absolutely nuts.’
Other high-profile Tories, including business secretary Kemi Badenoch, a Cabinet minister, also opposed the bill.
Prominent voices within the Conservative Party, including two of Sunak’s predecessors, Boris Johnson and Liz Truss, said the plans went against conservative values by limiting people’s personal freedoms.
Truss told Parliament during Tuesday’s debate that ‘We’re a free country. We shouldn’t be telling people not to smoke.’
