Former Gateway Church Pastor Robert Morris Accused of Child Sex Abuse: A Look at the Controversial Phone Call and Proposed Legislation

Southlake, Texas United States of America
Allegations date back to the 1980s when Morris is said to have abused a young girl named Cindy Clemishire beginning when she was 12 years old
Morris initially denied allegations but later confessed and resigned in 1987
Robert Morris, former pastor of Gateway Church in Texas, accused of child sexual abuse
State Representative Steve Toth plans to address issue with proposed legislation, including raising penalties for abusers and mandating church board members as mandatory reporters
Transcript of phone call on September 22, 2005, reveals Morris asked for payment to keep quiet about assaults
Former Gateway Church Pastor Robert Morris Accused of Child Sex Abuse: A Look at the Controversial Phone Call and Proposed Legislation

In recent news, a scandal has erupted at Gateway Church in Texas following allegations of child sexual abuse against its founder and former pastor, Robert Morris. The accusations date back to the 1980s when Morris is said to have abused a young girl named Cindy Clemishire beginning when she was just 12 years old. The abuse reportedly took place in both Texas and Oklahoma.

Morris, who grew to prominence as an evangelical adviser to former President Donald Trump and hosted him at Gateway Church in Dallas in 2020, initially denied the allegations when they were first brought forward. However, he later confessed to engaging in 'inappropriate sexual behavior with a young lady' and resigned from the church in March 1987.

The latest development in this scandal came to light when it was revealed that Morris had asked Clemishire for a price to keep quiet about the assaults during a phone call on September 22, 2005. The transcript of this conversation was obtained by NBC News through a former Gateway staff member.

Despite these revelations, some question the effectiveness of mandatory reporting legislation and believe that opening a 'look-back window' for victims to file civil cases against their abusers even after the statute of limitations has expired would be more beneficial. This is because many victims, like Clemishire, may not come forward until much later in life due to fear or shame.

State Representative Steve Toth plans to address this issue by raising the penalty for abusers and mandating church board members to become mandatory reporters. He also intends to educate district attorneys on the necessity of prosecuting and indicting individuals who helped conceal child sex abuse as part of his proposed legislation.

It is important to note that while this article provides factual information, it does not draw conclusions or make calls to action. The goal is to provide a comprehensive and unbiased account of the situation.



Confidence

91%

Doubts
  • It's unclear if any other individuals were involved in helping Morris conceal the abuse beyond what has been reported
  • The transcript of the phone call was obtained through a former Gateway staff member, but there is no confirmation of their identity or credibility

Sources

85%

  • Unique Points
    • Robert Morris, founder of Gateway Church, resigned after admitting to ‘inappropriate sexual behavior’ with a 12-year-old girl in the 1980s.
    • The allegations were first published on The Wartburg Watch blog by Cindy Clemishire who accused Morris of molesting her for several years, beginning when she was 12.
    • Morris grew to prominence after serving as an evangelical adviser to former President Donald Trump and hosting him at Gateway Church in Dallas in 2020.
    • The abuse began on Christmas night of 1982 and continued for more than four years, taking place in Texas and Oklahoma.
    • Clemishire sent an email directly to Morris’ Gateway email address in 2005, and former elder Tom Lane acknowledged the dates and details of her allegations. However, church leadership believed Morris’ false narrative at the time.
    • Gateway Church hired law firm Haynes and Boone to launch an independent inquiry into the case.
  • Accuracy
    • Robert Morris resigned after admitting to 'inappropriate sexual behavior' with a 12-year-old girl in the 1980s.
    • Morris did not respond to NPR’s request for comment.
  • Deception (50%)
    The article reports on allegations of child molestation made against Pastor Robert Morris of Gateway Church. The author does not make any editorializing or pontification statements, but the article does contain selective reporting and emotional manipulation. The article only reports details that support the allegations against Morris, while omitting any information that may cast doubt on them or present a different perspective. For example, the article states that Morris has not been charged with any crime but fails to mention that he has denied the allegations. Additionally, the article uses emotional language such as 'scandal roiling,' 'fallout,' and 'shocked, devastated and grieving' to manipulate readers' emotions and make them more receptive to the allegations.
    • Accusations of child molestation from decades ago have brought down a pastor who founded one of the largest megachurches in the U.S.
    • The scandal roiling one of the nation’s biggest megachurches, explained
    • Morris resigned from his post at Gateway on June 18, after admitting to abusing Clemishire.
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The article contains several instances of appeal to authority fallacies. The author relies on the statements of Cindy Clemishire and Tom Lane without providing any evidence or context to support their credibility beyond their assertions. Additionally, the author quotes Gateway Church elders denying knowledge of Morris's past actions and expressing shock and compassion for Clemishire, but there is no evidence provided to support these statements or indicate that they are speaking from firsthand knowledge. The article also contains inflammatory rhetoric in the form of descriptions of Morris as a 'megachurch founder' and 'evangelical adviser to former President Trump,' which may influence readers' perceptions without providing any relevant information.
    • The blog shared the account of Cindy Clemishire, who accused Morris of molesting her for several years, beginning when she was 12.
    • Tom Lane, a former Gateway elder, acknowledged that the sexual abuse began on December 25, 1982.
    • As an elder, I did not know the truth. And frankly, like so many of you, my wife and I are shocked, devastated and grieving.
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

86%

  • Unique Points
    • In September 2005, Robert Morris called Cindy Clemishire regarding her accusation of sexual abuse during her childhood.
    • During the call, Morris asked Clemishire what it would take for her not to go public with her accusation.
    • Clemishire responded that it was not about money but later mentioned a figure of two million dollars. Morris ended the conversation after Clemishire mentioned the figure.
  • Accuracy
    No Contradictions at Time Of Publication
  • Deception (50%)
    The author, Mike Hixenbaugh, reports on a phone conversation between Robert Morris and Cindy Clemishire in which Morris asks for a price to prevent her from going public with her accusation of sexual abuse. This is an example of selective reporting as the article only reports details that support the author's position, while omitting information that may contradict it or provide context. The article does not disclose any sources and there are no quotes from Morris denying the allegations or explaining his side of the story.
    • Clemishire responded, 'Money doesn’t make you happy and I can understand that. So that is not what this is about.' Morris again pressed her to name a figure.
    • Robert Morris wanted to know what it was going to take to prevent the woman on the phone from going public with her accusation that he'd sexually abused her as a child. 'Put a price on it,' Morris said on Sept. 22, 2005, according to a document that appears to be a transcript of a phone call.
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The author, Mike Hixenbaugh, uses inflammatory rhetoric by describing the phone call between Robert Morris and Cindy Clemishire as 'blunt' and 'reveals a blunt call'. This is an attempt to elicit an emotional response from the reader without providing any actual evidence of wrongdoing on Morris's part. Additionally, there is an example of appeal to authority when the author mentions that Morris served on former President Donald Trump's spiritual advisory board.
    • ‘Put a price on it’: Transcript reveals blunt call between megachurch pastor and his accuser
    • The document was provided to NBC News by a former Gateway staff member.
    • Morris, who served on former President Donald Trump’s spiritual advisory board, resigned last week from Gateway, the megachurch in Southlake, Texas, he founded 24 years ago.
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

98%

  • Unique Points
    • Robert Morris, a Southlake megachurch minister, resigned after being accused of sexual abuse by a woman named Cindy Clemishire.
    • Clemishire claimed the abuse began when she was 12 years old in 1982.
    • Morris admitted to ‘kissing and petting’ a ‘young woman’ on ‘several occasions’.
    • State Rep. Steve Toth proposed raising the penalty for abusers and mandating church board members to become mandatory reporters.
    • Michelle Simpson Tuegel, a victim’s rights attorney, doesn’t believe mandatory reporting legislation is the most effective course for helping victims.
    • District attorneys seldom pursue charges against individuals who failed to report abuse.
    • Toth plans to educate district attorneys on the necessity of prosecuting and indicting individuals who helped conceal child sex abuse as part of his proposed legislation.
    • Opening a ‘look-back window’ that grants victims a chance to file a civil case against their abusers even after the statute of limitations has expired is more effective, according to Tuegel.
    • Victims have until they turn 40 in Texas to report their crime in civil cases.
    • Clemishire’s alleged abuse took place before she turned 20, so the statute of limitations expired for her.
  • Accuracy
    • Robert Morris admitted to 'kissing and petting' a 'young woman' on 'several occasions'. (article)
    • Morris asked Clemishire for a price to keep quiet about the assaults in 2005. (otherArticles[1], otherArticles[3])
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

79%

  • Unique Points
    • Robert Morris asked Clemishire for a price to keep quiet about the assaults in 2005.
    • Morris confessed to engaging in ‘inappropriate sexual behavior with a young lady’ and resigned from Gateway Church in March 1987.
    • The assaults occurred at Clemishire’s family home where Morris was staying.
  • Accuracy
    No Contradictions at Time Of Publication
  • Deception (30%)
    The author makes no editorializing or pontification in this article. However, there are instances of selective reporting and sensationalism. The author only reports details that support the allegations made by Cindy Clemishire against Robert Morris. For example, the title of the article states that Morris 'asked accuser for price to keep quiet.' This implies that a monetary transaction occurred between them, which is not explicitly stated in the article. The author also reports on specific instances of alleged sexual misconduct by Morris without mentioning any potential context or mitigating factors. Additionally, the author quotes Clemishire's statements about wanting compensation for her trauma and Morris's response to that request, but does not provide any context for why these conversations occurred or what led up to them. These selective reporting and sensationalistic elements of the article reduce its overall credibility and accuracy.
    • When Clemishire responded that it was 'not a small number,' Morris pushed back after noting that money did not make her happy and he could understand that. 'Two million dollars,' Clemishire responded before Morris ended the call, the transcript states.
    • Ex-Trump Spiritual Advisor Robert Morris Asked Accuser for Price to Keep Quiet, Report Says
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The author makes an appeal to authority by reporting on the statements made by Cindy Clemishire and Robert Morris without providing any context or analysis. The author also uses inflammatory rhetoric by describing the phone call between Morris and Clemishire as 'shocking' and 'alarming'. No formal fallacies were found.
    • ]Put a price on it[
    • When I was in my early twenties, I was involved in inappropriate sexual behavior with a young lady.
  • Bias (80%)
    The author, Pilar Melendez, demonstrates a clear bias towards portraying Robert Morris in a negative light. She uses language that depicts him as someone who tried to buy the silence of an accuser and someone who engaged in 'inappropriate sexual behavior'. While these statements may be true, they are not neutral and can be perceived as biased.
    • But the shocking phone conversation came after emails between Clemishire and Morris in which she asked for compensation over her trauma.
      • Morris took steps to pay off Clemishire in 2005 in a series of emails.
        • The shocking phone conversation did not lead to the downfall of the Texas megachurch pastor who would go on to serve as former President Donald Trump’s spiritual adviser.
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication

        94%

        • Unique Points
          • New fallout occurred after the accusation on Monday
        • Accuracy
          • Pastor of one of the biggest churches in Texas was accused of child sexual abuse
          • Robert Morris admitted to ‘kissing and petting’ a ‘young woman’ on ‘several occasions’.
          • Morris asked Clemishire for a price to keep quiet about the assaults in 2005.
        • Deception (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Fallacies (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Bias (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication