Russia's Repression of Women's Rights: The Case of Daria Serenko and Zalina Marshenkulova

Moscow, Moscow Oblast or Moscow City Russian Federation
Both women were added to Russia's federal wanted list due to their opposition to the Russian invasion of Ukraine
`Female Anti-war Resistance` is a feminist movement standing against historical suppression of women's voices and agency in Russia
Restrictions on women's rights and freedoms have intensified under Putin's regime, perpetuating patriarchal norms that devalue and marginalize women
Russia has opened criminal cases against two prominent Russian feminist activists, Daria Serenko and Zalina Marshenkulova
The Russian military is gradually expanding the role of women as it seeks new recruits for the war in Ukraine
Zalina Marshenkulova discussed the Kremlin's increasing pressure on women's rights campaigners in a podcast called 'Russia on the Record'
Russia's Repression of Women's Rights: The Case of Daria Serenko and Zalina Marshenkulova

In recent times, the role of women in Russia has been under increasing scrutiny, particularly as it pertains to their involvement in military conflicts. As Russia faces accusations of targeting feminist activists, there is a growing concern about the treatment and rights of women within the country. In April 2024, reports emerged that Russia had opened criminal cases against two prominent Russian feminist activists, Daria Serenko and Zalina Marshenkulova. Though both women now live abroad, they were added to Russia's federal wanted list due to their opposition to the Russian invasion of Ukraine. This incident highlights the Kremlin's repression of women's rights activists and its increasing pressure on women's rights campaigners in Russia.

Zalina Marshenkulova, a feminist activist, discusses the Kremlin's increasing pressure on women's rights campaigners and the influence of the feminist movement in Russia. She also addresses her addition to Russia's federal wanted list during a podcast called 'Russia on the Record.' The podcast is available on various platforms including Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, Google Podcasts, and YouTube.

Simultaneously, women in Russia face systemic issues that stifle their potential and silence their voices. Early 20th-century efforts by women to carve a space for their voices were swiftly stifled by the male-dominated Bolshevik elite. The Soviet era did little to advance women's rights, often relegating women to traditional roles under the guise of socialist equality. Feminist movements such as the Female Anti-war Resistance stand as beacons of defiance against historical suppression of women's voices and agency.

Under Putin's regime, restrictions on women's rights and freedoms have intensified, perpetuating patriarchal norms that devalue and marginalize women. The Russian army is gradually expanding the role of women as it seeks to balance President Vladimir Putin's promotion of traditional family roles with the need for new recruits for the war in Ukraine. The military's stepped-up appeal to women includes efforts to recruit female inmates in prisons, replicating on a much smaller scale a strategy that has swelled its ranks with male convicts.

In light of these developments, it is crucial to examine the influence of Russia's feminist movement and whether women's rights activists are the next target of the Kremlin's repressions. With increasing pressure on women's rights campaigners and a growing emphasis on traditional family roles, it remains to be seen how Russia will navigate its treatment of women in the future.



Confidence

85%

Doubts
  • `Female Anti-war Resistance` is an accurate and established name for the movement
  • The Russian military's efforts to recruit female inmates are directly linked to Putin's promotion of traditional family roles

Sources

66%

  • Unique Points
    • Russian army is expanding the role of women in the military to balance traditional family roles and the need for new recruits for the war in Ukraine.
    • Recruiters offer pardons and high salaries to female inmates for serving in front-line roles.
    • Dozens of female inmates have signed military contracts or applied to enlist after being offered a pardon and high salary.
  • Accuracy
    • ]Russian army is expanding the role of women in the military to balance traditional family roles and the need for new recruits for the war in Ukraine.[
    • The Russian military’s need to replenish its ranks for the long-term war against Ukraine has clashed with Putin’s ideological struggle.
  • Deception (30%)
    The article contains selective reporting as it only reports details that support the authors' position about women being recruited into the Russian military. It does not mention or provide context about the larger conflict in Ukraine or Russia's motivations for recruiting women. The article also uses emotional manipulation by describing how some female soldiers feel 'mad' and 'frustrated' when they are not allowed to fight on the front lines due to their gender.
    • Ilyasova and six other women fighting for Russia in Ukraine said local recruitment offices still routinely turned away female volunteers or sent them to reserves.
    • Recruiters in military uniforms toured Russian jails for women in the fall of 2023, offering inmates a pardon and $2,000 a month – 10 times the national minimum wage – in return for serving in front-line roles for a year.
    • Some female volunteers do not make it to Ukraine. The convicts who enlisted in late 2023 have yet to be sent to fight.
    • The Russian army is gradually expanding the role of women as it seeks to balance President Vladimir Putin’s promotion of traditional family roles with the need for new recruits for the war in Ukraine.
  • Fallacies (75%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (80%)
    The authors present a balanced view of the situation, but there are some instances of language that could be perceived as biased. The authors use the term 'convicts' to describe women who have signed up to fight in the war, potentially depicting them in a negative light. They also mention that these women spoke on condition of anonymity for fear of possible retribution, which could imply that they are hiding something shameful. Additionally, there is a quote from Ksenia Shkoda where she mentions being looked at like a monkey when she is in fatigues, which could be seen as an example of gender bias. However, overall the authors present factual information and do not show any clear bias towards or against any particular side.
    • Ksenia Shkoda: “I have gotten used to the fact that I am often looked at like a monkey — like, ‘Wow, she’s in fatigues!’”
      • women spoke on the condition of anonymity for fear of possible retribution.
      • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication

      95%

      • Unique Points
        • In April, Russia opened criminal cases against two Russian feminist activists: Daria Serenko and Zalina Marshenkulova.
        • Both women are founders of Feminist Anti-War Resistance and openly opposed the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
        • They now live abroad but were added to Russia’s federal wanted list.
        • Zalina Marshenkulova discusses the Kremlin’s increasing pressure on women’s rights campaigners, the feminist movement’s influence, and her addition to Russia’s federal wanted list in a podcast called ‘Russia on the Record.’
      • Accuracy
        • ]In April, Russia opened criminal cases against two Russian feminist activists: Daria Serenko and Zalina Marshenkulova.[
      • Deception (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Fallacies (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Bias (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication

      86%

      • Unique Points
        • Women in Russia face systemic issues that stifle their potential and silence their voices
        • Early 20th century efforts by women to carve a space for their voices were swiftly stifled by the male-dominated Bolshevik elite
        • The Soviet era did little to advance women's rights, often relegating women to traditional roles under the guise of socialist equality
        • Feminist movements such as the Female Anti-war Resistance stand as beacons of defiance against historical suppression of women's voices and agency
        • Under Putin's regime, restrictions on women's rights and freedoms have intensified, perpetuating patriarchal norms that devalue and marginalize women
      • Accuracy
        • The Soviet era did little to advance women’s rights, often relegating women to traditional roles under the guise of socialist equality
        • Feminist movements such as the Female Anti-war Resistance stand as beacons of defiance against historical suppression of women’s voices and agency
        • The 1990s marked a pivotal moment in the narrative of Russian women, with societal view of women marginalizing them and setting the stage for deteriorating situation under Putin’s rule
        • Under Putin’s regime, restrictions on women’s rights and freedoms have intensified, perpetuating patriarchal norms that devalue and marginalize women
        • Female politicians, journalists, and public figures are often judged and criticized for their appearance and personal lives to divert attention from their ideas
        • The ridicule of female voices is a political strategy designed to maintain the status quo by side-lining valuable contributions of women
      • Deception (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Fallacies (85%)
        The article contains a few instances of appeals to authority and inflammatory rhetoric but no formal or dichotomous fallacies. The author cites historical context and interviews with experts to support their claims, which is valid in reporting but can be seen as an appeal to authority. Additionally, there are some instances of inflammatory language used when describing the Russian government's actions and treatment of women.
        • The history of feminism in Russia is a tale of silence and suppression...
        • The Soviet era, with its veneer of gender equality, did little to advance women's rights...
        • Under his regime, restrictions on women's rights and freedoms have intensified...
        • In Russia's male-dominated public and political discourse, female politicians, journalists, and public figures are often judged and criticized for their appearance...
      • Bias (95%)
        The author expresses a clear bias towards the empowerment of women in Russia and against the patriarchal norms that devalue and marginalize women. She uses language that depicts Russian women as being silenced, erased from public discourse, and reduced to mere shadows of their potential. The author also implies that Putin's regime is responsible for this state of affairs.
        • Beneath the glittering domes of Moscow and the power corridors of the Kremlin lies a shadow war that’s not fought with guns or drones, but with silence and stigma. It’s a war against women, against their voices, and their rightful place in Russian society.
          • Despite their vocal opposition, these groups have received scant support from abroad, a gap that needs to be urgently addressed.
            • The absence of female leaders in the country, the silencing of dissenting female journalists, and the ridicule of women for aspects of their personal lives – rather than their ideas or contributions – paint a stark picture of female disempowerment.
            • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
              None Found At Time Of Publication
            • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
              None Found At Time Of Publication