Remembering Tiananmen: Commemorations and Suppression in Beijing and Hong Kong on the 35th Anniversary

Beijing, Beijing Municipality China
An estimated 180,000 troops and armed police were deployed in Beijing to end pro-democracy protests.
Despite efforts to suppress memories of Tiananmen in China, Taiwan President William Lai Ching-te promised historical memory would last forever.
In Hong Kong, overseas communities carried on commemorations and performance artist Sanmu Chen was detained.
The 35th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown saw heightened security in China to suppress commemoration.
The Chinese government has never released an official death toll from the crackdown.
Remembering Tiananmen: Commemorations and Suppression in Beijing and Hong Kong on the 35th Anniversary

The 35th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown saw heightened security in China as the Chinese government sought to suppress any mention or commemoration of the event. The bloody military intervention, which took place on June 3-4, 1989, resulted in an estimated death toll of hundreds to thousands. The Chinese government has long censored any discussion of the Tiananmen Square protests and crackdown both on the mainland and in Hong Kong.

In Beijing, an estimated 180,000 troops and armed police were deployed to end the pro-democracy protests that had been ongoing for months. The Chinese government has never released an official death toll from the crackdown. In Hong Kong, which was once a beacon of commemorative freedom for Tiananmen victims, overseas communities carried on the torch to keep memories alive.

Rowena He, a prominent scholar of the Tiananmen Square crackdown, traveled between the United States, Britain and Canada to give talks aimed at speaking out for those who cannot. In London, 'May 35th' was performed as a play that told the story of an elderly couple who wished to properly mourn their son who died in 1989. A museum dedicated to the Tiananmen crackdown opened in New York last June and featured exhibits such as a blood-stained shirt and a tent used by student protesters.

In Hong Kong, performance artist Sanmu Chen was detained on the eve of the anniversary for miming drinking in front of a police van and chanting 'Hong Kongers, do not be afraid. Don't forget tomorrow is June 4.' Three former leaders of the group organizing an annual vigil were charged with subversion under Hong Kong's national security law and the group was disbanded.

Despite efforts to suppress memories of Tiananmen in China, Taiwan President William Lai Ching-te promised that historical memory would last forever. Beijing has not ruled out using force to take control of Taiwan and staged war games around the island after Lai's inauguration.



Confidence

90%

Doubts
  • It is unclear how many people were actually detained in Hong Kong for commemorating the anniversary.
  • The Chinese government's official death toll from the Tiananmen Square crackdown is unknown.

Sources

99%

  • Unique Points
    • Jeff Widener took the iconic photo of an unidentified man blocking tanks on Beijing's Avenue of Eternal Peace during the crackdown.
    • Widener smuggled equipment and film past authorities to take photos from a hotel room overlooking Tiananmen Square.
    • Kirk Martsen helped Widener enter the hotel by letting him into his room.
    • Jonathan Schaer set up a camera on the balcony of CNN’s room at the hotel and captured footage of the event.
  • Accuracy
    • ]The death toll from the crackdown remains unknown, with hundreds to thousands believed to have been killed[1], [Estimates of deaths range from several hundred to thousands][2]
    • China heavily censors any mention or reference of the Tiananmen Square crackdown on social media[3], [Discussion of Tiananmen has become taboo on the mainland since the crackdown][4]
    • Hong Kong was the only Chinese territory that held a memorial for Tiananmen Square until 2020, but it is now banned and its organizers jailed[5], [The annual vigil in Hong Kong’s Victoria Park to remember the Tiananmen Square crackdown has disappeared due to the national security law imposed by Beijing in 2020][6]
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

95%

  • Unique Points
    • China heightened security on the 35th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown
    • Estimated 180,000 troops and armed police were involved in the operation to end pro-democracy protests in Beijing
    • The death toll from the crackdown remains unknown, with hundreds to thousands believed to have been killed
    • China heavily censors any mention or reference of the Tiananmen Square crackdown on social media
    • Three former leaders of a group organizing an annual vigil were charged with subversion and the group was disbanded in 2021
  • Accuracy
    • Estimated 180,000 troops and armed police were involved in the operation to end pro-democracy protests in Beijing (article) vs Estimates of deaths range from several hundred to thousands (otherArticles)
    • The death toll from the crackdown remains unknown, with hundreds to thousands believed to have been killed (article) vs Estimates of deaths range from several hundred to thousands (otherArticles)
    • China heavily censors any mention or reference of the Tiananmen Square crackdown on social media (article) vs Several pro-democracy activists have been approached by police about their plans for Tuesday, the anniversary of the crackdown (otherArticles)
    • Three former leaders of a group organizing an annual vigil were charged with subversion and the group was disbanded in 2021 (article) vs Three leaders of the group that organized the vigil in Hong Kong were charged with subversion under a 2020 sweeping national security law. The group later voted to disband (otherArticles)
    • Some residents remembered the event privately by running 6.4 kilometers on June 4 or sharing Tiananmen-related content on social media (article) vs Hundreds of police have been deployed to keep watch in sensitive locations (otherArticles)
    • Authorities ramped up efforts to erase reminders of the crackdown, including questioning activists about their plans for commemorative events and detaining a performance artist and recording customers’ identity details at an independent bookstore (article) vs A museum dedicated to the Tiananmen crackdown opened in New York last June and features exhibits such as a blood-stained shirt and a tent used by student protesters (otherArticles)
    • Commemorative events have grown overseas as China cracks down on memories of Tiananmen in Hong Kong and the mainland (article) vs Overseas memorial events are crucial because mainland Chinese and Hong Kongers can see overseas memorial activities online (otherArticles)
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The article reports on current events and quotes officials without endorsing their views. However, it does not directly quote any primary sources from the protests or provide counterarguments to the official Chinese government narrative. There is a dichotomous depiction of the Chinese government's actions and censorship, but no formal fallacies are committed by the author.
    • China has long quashed any memory of the killings...
    • Across China, the event remains a sensitive and taboo subject that is heavily censored...
    • Asked by a foreign journalist for comment on the 35th anniversary during a daily foreign ministry briefing on Monday, spokesperson Mao Ning shrugged off the event. [...]
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

98%

  • Unique Points
    • Hong Kong police detained performance artist Sanmu Chen on the eve of the 35th anniversary of China’s Tiananmen Square crackdown.
    • Chen was detained in Causeway Bay, a shopping district near a park that used to host an annual vigil for Tiananmen victims.
    • Three former leaders of the vigil organizing group were charged with subversion under the national security law.
  • Accuracy
    • The annual vigil in Hong Kong's Victoria Park to remember the Tiananmen crackdown has disappeared due to the national security law imposed by Beijing in 2020.
    • Tiananmen-related statues have been removed from universities in Hong Kong.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

95%

  • Unique Points
    • Tiananmen Square protests took place in 1989 where students and workers had set up camp for weeks.
    • Chinese soldiers stormed the square, opening fire and killing hundreds to thousands of people.
    • Discussion of Tiananmen has become taboo on the mainland since the crackdown.
    • Hong Kong was the only Chinese territory that held a memorial for Tiananmen Square until 2020, but it is now banned and its organizers jailed.
    • Taiwan President William Lai Ching-te promised to make sure that historical memory lasts forever and will not be forgotten.
    • Beijing has not ruled out using force to take control of Taiwan and staged war games around the island after Lai’s inauguration.
  • Accuracy
    • The Tiananmen Square protests took place in 1989.
    • An official death toll has never been released.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (90%)
    The article contains a few inflammatory rhetorical statements and appeals to authority but no formal logical fallacies. Taiwan's President William Lai is quoted making some assertions that could be seen as an appeal to authority, particularly when he discusses Taiwan's transition from an authoritarian military regime to a thriving democracy. The article also includes inflammatory language such as describing Beijing's 1989 crackdown on protesters as 'brutal' and referring to the Chinese government's handling of the Tiananmen issue as a 'taboo'. However, these are more reflective of the author's opinion rather than a logical fallacy. There are no examples of false claims or faulty reasoning.
    • ] Taiwan President William Lai Ching-te has promised Beijing’s brutal 1989 crackdown on protesters in Tiananmen Square will not be forgotten, as Hong Kong deployed hundreds of police to keep an eye out for potential commemorative activities.
    • The memory of June 4th will not disappear in the torrent of history.
    • Chinese and Hong Kong exiles joined activists in Canada, the United Kingdom, the United States and elsewhere to remember the events of June 1989.
  • Bias (95%)
    Al Jazeera's article focuses on the anniversary of the Tiananmen Square protests and Beijing's efforts to suppress commemoration of the event. The author quotes Taiwan President William Lai Ching-te making statements about remembering June 4th and working hard to make this historical memory last forever. The article also mentions China's crackdown on discussion of Tiananmen, arrests related to social media posts, and Hong Kong's ban on the annual vigil. These quotes and facts are presented in a neutral manner but the author's choice to focus on these topics and their framing implies a critical stance towards China's handling of the situation. The article does not use language that depicts one side as extreme or unreasonable, but it does use strong words like 'brutal', 'taboo', and 'erased' to describe China's actions.
    • In recent days, eight people have been arrested for alleged sedition over social media posts related to Tiananmen in the first arrests under Hong Kong’s domestic national security law, which exists in addition to a sweeping security law imposed by China in 2020.
      • Taiwan President William Lai Ching-te has promised Beijing’s brutal 1989 crackdown on protesters in Tiananmen Square will not be forgotten, as Hong Kong deployed hundreds of police to keep an eye out for potential commemorative activities.
      • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication

      99%

      • Unique Points
        • Rowena He, a prominent scholar of the Tiananmen Square crackdown, has been flying between the United States, Britain and Canada to give a series of talks aimed at speaking out for those who cannot.
        • 'May 35th', which subtly references the June 4 crackdown, has been performed in London. It tells the story of an elderly couple who wish to properly mourn their son who died in 1989.
        • A museum dedicated to the Tiananmen crackdown opened in New York last June and features exhibits such as a blood-stained shirt and a tent used by student protesters.
        • Overseas memorial events are crucial because mainland Chinese and Hong Kongers can see overseas memorial activities online.
      • Accuracy
        • The upcoming quarterly refunding update from the US Treasury will provide information on how much bond supply there will be.
        • China heightened security on the 35th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown
        • Hong Kong's massive June 4 annual vigil mourning the victims of the Tiananmen Square crackdown has vanished due to the city’s clampdown on dissidents following huge anti-government protests in 2019.
        • Beijing’s toughened political stance has effectively extinguished any large-scale commemorations within its borders, making overseas commemorative events increasingly crucial for preserving memories of the Tiananmen crackdown.
      • Deception (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Fallacies (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Bias (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication