Tragic History: The Shooting of Sonya Massey and the Lynching of William Donnegan - Racial Injustice in Springfield, Illinois

Springfield, Illinois United States of America
Both incidents sparked calls for racial justice and renewed attention to the history of racial injustice in Springfield, Illinois.
Sonya Massey, a 36-year-old Black woman, was shot by Deputy Sean Grayson in her home on July 6, 2024.
The shooting of Sonya Massey brought renewed attention to the lynching of William Donnegan in Springfield in 1908.
William Donnegan, an 84-year-old Black man, was lynched by a White mob after being accused of raping a White woman in 1908.
Tragic History: The Shooting of Sonya Massey and the Lynching of William Donnegan - Racial Injustice in Springfield, Illinois

Title: A Tragic History of Racial Injustice in Springfield, Illinois: The Cases of Sonya Massey and William Donnegan

Paragraph 1: In the heart of Illinois lies the city of Springfield, a place steeped in history and tradition. However, this city's past is not without its dark moments. Two tragic incidents, separated by over a century, have brought calls for racial justice to the forefront once again.

Paragraph 2: On July 6, 2024, Sonya Massey, a 36-year-old Black woman from Springfield, called the authorities reporting an intruder in her home. Deputy Sean Grayson and another officer arrived at the scene but found no evidence of a break-in. After knocking on the door to ask for identification, they entered Massey's home when she failed to respond promptly.

Paragraph 3: The situation escalated quickly, with Massey trying to protect herself and her property. She was shot by Deputy Grayson in her kitchen. The shooting sparked outrage and calls for justice, as well as renewed attention to the long history of racial injustice in Springfield.

Paragraph 4: Nearly 116 years prior to this event, an equally tragic incident occurred at St. John's Hospital in Springfield. An 84-year-old Black man named William Donnegan was lynched by a White mob after being accused of raping a White woman.

Paragraph 5: Both tragedies drew national attention and sparked calls for racial justice. The stories of Sonya Massey and William Donnegan serve as stark reminders of the long history of racial injustice in Springfield, Illinois.

Background Information: Springfield is a city rich in history, having served as the capital city of Illinois since 1837. It is most famous for being the home town of Abraham Lincoln. However, its past is not without blemishes.

Paragraph 6: the Illinois State Register reported that Donnegan was a shoemaker and had once been a conductor on the Underground Railroad before settling in Springfield. He was lynched on August 14, 1908, after being accused of raping a White woman named Teresa Haley.

Paragraph 7: The incident sparked riots and violence in Springfield, with the African American community suffering greatly. The Illinois State Journal reported that several Black-owned businesses were destroyed during the unrest.

Paragraph 8: the shooting of Sonya Massey brought renewed attention to these past events and once again put Springfield at the center of national conversations around racial justice in America.

Conclusion: The tragic stories of Sonya Massey and William Donnegan serve as a reminder that the fight for racial justice is not over. It is important to remember our history, learn from it, and continue working towards a more equitable society.



Confidence

70%

Doubts
  • Are there any recent studies or reports that show a pattern of police brutality against Black individuals in Springfield?

Sources

76%

  • Unique Points
    • Sean P. Grayson had a disciplinary file that included accusations of bullying behavior and abuse of power.
    • Grayson's disciplinary file also documented an incident where he pressured Girard Police Chief Wayman Meredith to call child protective services on a woman outside Grayson’s mother’s home.
    • Supervising officers were concerned about Grayson’s behavior, including his lack of integrity, lying in reports, and what they called ‘official misconduct’.
    • Grayson was arrested and charged with first-degree murder, aggravated battery with a firearm, and official misconduct in the shooting of Sonya Massey. He has pleaded not guilty.
    • Grayson was hired by the Sangamon County Sheriff’s Office shortly after leaving Logan County, where he had worked for less than a year.
  • Accuracy
    • Sean Grayson had disciplinary record that included accusations of bullying behavior and abuse of power.
  • Deception (30%)
    The article contains selective reporting as it only reports details that support the author's position of Grayson's past misconduct. The author also uses emotional manipulation by describing Grayson as 'steaming mad' and 'acting like a bully'. There is no clear editorializing or pontification from the author, but there are quotes from others that could be considered opinionated.
    • New details reveal troubled past for deputy charged with murder in Sonya Massey shooting
    • The sheriff and I will not tolerate lying or deception.
    • He was acting like a bully.
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The author makes several statements that could be considered appeals to authority. The Girard Police Chief Wayman Meredith's statement about Grayson's behavior being 'not kosher' and his description of Grayson as 'acting like a bully' are examples of this fallacy. Additionally, the supervising officer at the Logan County Sheriff's Office warning Grayson that 'officers [like you] have been charged and they end up in jail' is another example. These statements do not provide any logical reasoning or evidence to support the author's claims about Grayson, but instead rely on the authority of these individuals to make their point.
    • Girard Police Chief Wayman Meredith: He was acting like a bully.
    • Supervising officer at the Logan County Sheriff's Office: officers [like you] have been charged and they end up in jail.
  • Bias (80%)
    The author uses language that depicts Grayson as a bully and someone who abuses his power. She quotes the police chief describing Grayson's behavior towards him as 'not kosher' and 'wanting me to do stuff that was not kosher'. The author also mentions an incident where Grayson is accused of harassing a man and woman at a traffic stop, barging into the hospital room while a doctor was performing a procedure on the woman, and pressuring the Girard police chief to call child protective services. These examples demonstrate bias towards portraying Grayson in a negative light.
    • Grayson was wanting me to do stuff that was not kosher.
      • He was acting like a bully.
      • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication

      98%

      • Unique Points
        • Sonya Massey, a 36-year-old Black woman, died after being shot in her home by a White sheriff’s deputy in St. John’s Hospital, Springfield, Illinois.
        • Nearly 116 years prior to this event, an 84-year-old Black man also died in the same hospital after being lynched by a White mob.
        • Both tragedies sparked calls for racial justice and drew national attention to Springfield.
        • In 1908, a mob in Springfield lynched an 84-year-old Black shoemaker named William Donnegan, who had once been a conductor on the Underground Railroad.
        • Springfield, Illinois, was once again at the center of national conversations around racial justice in America following Sonya Massey’s death.
      • Accuracy
        • Sonya Massey died after being shot in her home by a White sheriff’s deputy.
        • Sonya Massey was unarmed when she was shot by the deputy.
        • The encounter between Sonya Massey and the deputies escalated and resulted in her death.
      • Deception (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Fallacies (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Bias (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication

      80%

      • Unique Points
        • Sonya Massey called 911 reporting an intruder but no intruder was found
        • Deputy Sean Grayson questioned Massey about why she took so long to answer the door
        • Massey replied that she was trying to put on clothes before opening the door for the officers
        • Grayson asked if there was anything else they could do for her and Massey replied 'No, sir'
        • Grayson asked about Massey’s mental state and she replied that she had taken her medicine
        • Massey tried to close her front door but the officers entered her home to ask for identification
        • The officers found a pot of boiling water on the stove and ordered Massey to take it off the flame, causing one officer to back away when he realized it was hot
        • Massey said 'I rebuke you in the name of Jesus' when asked to show her ID
        • Grayson responded with anger and threatened to shoot Massey if she didn’t comply
        • Massey crouched down behind the kitchen counter in fear and apologized, but Grayson shot her in the face
      • Accuracy
        • Sonya Massey called 911 reporting an intruder
        • Deputy Sean Grayson and another officer found no intruder outside of her home
        • Massey went to turn off her stove after the officers knocked on her door. Within seconds, Grayson drew his gun and shot her in the head.
      • Deception (30%)
        The author uses emotional manipulation by describing the video of Sonya Massey's killing in a way that elicits strong emotions from the reader. She also uses selective reporting by focusing on details that support her argument and ignoring others. For example, she mentions that Grayson sounded suspicious when he asked why it took Massey so long to answer the door, but she does not mention that Massey had previously called 911 for a false alarm and had not answered the door when officers arrived earlier. This information would have given context to Grayson's question and could have been relevant to understanding his actions. The author also uses sensationalism by describing the video as 'the worst police-shooting video ever' without providing any evidence or explanation for this claim.
        • Me seeing this feels a violation. But the scene also feels familiar. I know firsthand that dirty dishes in a sink, clothes tossed throughout an apartment, or piles of junk can be the outward signs of deep personal struggles.
        • Grayson now faces charges including first-degree murder, to which he has pleaded not guilty.
        • Was it the intimacy of the video? Was it the image of Massey standing on her porch, as the light emanating from her living room highlighted her slender frame?
        • Let me tell you what I see and hear in the video of Sonya Massey’s killing: A nervous woman, head tilted down toward her phone, as if hoping someone—maybe a family member—has replied to her messages. A shaky voice wanting to hear words of reassurance.
        • Then Grayson asks about her mental state. Massey’s family has said that she had mental-health issues, and it’s clear the officer has concluded that something is wrong with her.
        • One of the officers backs away. Massey seems confused; she asks where he’s going. He tells her he doesn’t want to get hit by boiling water.
        • To the officers, this seems bizarre—understandably. But I’ve heard the phrase before, mainly because I have family members and friends who call on Jesus for all sorts of different reasons.
      • Fallacies (100%)
        None Found At Time Of Publication
      • Bias (80%)
        The author demonstrates ideological bias by framing the article around her personal experiences and emotions towards police violence and being Black in America. She uses language that depicts the officers as interrogating Sonya Massey unnecessarily and dismissive of her fears, while also portraying Sonya as a small, vulnerable woman who was trying to protect herself.
        • Grayson responds, the rage rolling off his tongue. ‘You better fucking not,’ Grayson says, ‘I’ll shoot you in your fucking face.’
          • Grayson sounds suspicious:
            • Her steady politeness reminded me of the way that many Black children are taught early on to interact with police officers: Always answer ‘Yes, sir’ or ‘No, sir.’ Assume that they’ll have negative assumptions about you, assumptions that you may need to defuse to protect yourself from getting hurt.
              • Instead, he sounds like he’s interrogating her.
                • One of the officers backs away. Massey seems confused; she asks where he’s going. He tells her he doesn’t want to get hit by boiling water.
                  • She is wearing a silky-looking cream-colored robe, so long that it brushes the ground; a T-shirt over pajama pants with a flamingo-pink string; and a headscarf like so many Black women wear while sleeping to protect our hair.
                    • To the officers, this seems bizarre
                    • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication
                    • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication

                    97%

                    • Unique Points
                      • On July 6, Sonya Massey called 911 to report an intruder.
                      • Deputy Sean Grayson and another officer found no intruder outside of her home in Sangamon County, Ill.
                      • Ms. Massey went to turn off her stove after the officers knocked on her door.
                      • Within seconds, Mr. Grayson drew his gun and shot her in the head.
                      • From 2016 to 2019, only 43 police officers were charged with murder or manslaughter related to an on-duty shooting.
                      • Deputy Sean Grayson was fired and charged with first-degree murder.
                    • Accuracy
                      • Sonya Massey was wearing a cream-colored robe, T-shirt over pajama pants with a flamingo-pink string, and a headscarf when they arrived
                      • Deputy Sean Grayson questioned Massey about why she took so long to answer the door
                      • Massey replied that she was trying to put on clothes before opening the door for the officers
                    • Deception (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication
                    • Fallacies (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication
                    • Bias (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication
                    • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication
                    • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication

                    97%

                    • Unique Points
                      • Sean Grayson was discharged from the U.S. Army for 'serious misconduct' in 2016.
                      • Grayson served in the U.S. Army as a Wheeled Vehicle Mechanic from May 2014 to February 2016, leaving in the rank of private first class.
                      • Grayson was hired for his first known police job at the Pawnee Police Department in August 2020 and was fired from his most recent job as a sheriff's deputy at the Sangamon County Sheriff's Department after the July 6 deadly shooting of Massey.
                      • Grayson worked for six law enforcement agencies over the last four years: Auburn Police Department, Logan County Sheriff's Office, Sangamon County Sheriff's Office, Kincaid Police Department, Pawnee Police Department and Virden Police Department.
                    • Accuracy
                      • ,
                    • Deception (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication
                    • Fallacies (95%)
                      The author provides detailed information about the deputy's military discharge and DUI offenses without making any fallacious statements. However, there is an instance of inflammatory rhetoric when the author describes Grayson's misconduct as 'serious.' This does not significantly impact the overall score as it is a minor infraction.
                      • The U.S. Army, citing the Privacy Act and Department of Defense policy, said it is prevented from releasing information relating to the misconduct of low-level employees or characterization of service at discharge.
                    • Bias (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication
                    • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication
                    • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                      None Found At Time Of Publication