Smithsonian Magazine Online Edition (www.smithsonianmag.com)
A news site that covers various topics such as science, arts and culture. It has a bias towards presenting controversial or sensationalist stories without providing enough context or evidence to support them.
78%
The Daily's Verdict
This news site has a mixed reputation for journalistic standards. It is advisable to fact-check, scrutinize for bias, and check for conflicts of interest before relying on its reporting.
Bias
100%
Examples:
- The article presents the debate as a simple question of classification when in fact there are many other factors at play such as bone maturity and predator coexistence.
- The article quotes experts who have different opinions on the matter without providing any context or explanation for their positions. This creates an impression that these opinions are equally valid when in reality one position is more supported by evidence than the other.
Conflicts of Interest
50%
Examples:
- A previous fossil discovery was found to represent a juvenile Tyrannosaurus with distinctive features that ally it with T. rex but not seen in Nanotyrannus
- This could indicate a conflict of interest or bias on the part of the researchers who made this claim, as they may have overlooked other possible explanations for these features.
Contradictions
100%
Examples:
- A previous fossil discovery was found to represent a juvenile Tyrannosaurus with distinctive features that ally it with T. rex but not seen in Nanotyrannus
- Modelling the growth of Nanotyrannus showed it would have reached a maximum size around 900-1500 kilograms and five metres - about 15 per cent of T. rex, which grew to 8,000 kilograms and nine meters or more
- The first skull of Nanotyrannus was found in Montana in 1942, but for decades paleontologists have gone back and forth on whether it was a separate species or simply a juvenile T. rex
Deceptions
80%
Examples:
- The article does not provide any evidence or sources for these claims, which could be seen as deceptive.
- The article uses sensationalist language such as ‘Amazing Fossil Preserves Teenage Tyrannosaur’s Last Meal’ to attract readers and create a false impression of the scientific rigor of the research.