On March 24, a search and rescue effort for a missing 6-year-old girl named Linajah Brooker who was swept away by Chester Creek in Delaware County, Pennsylvania transitioned to a recovery mission. The decision was made on Sunday after the Coast Guard continued searching through the night while several fire companies took part in the initial search. Boats with thermal imaging were also used to scan the water on Saturday night while crews searched through nearby trees and debris.
On March 24, a search and rescue effort for a missing 6-year-old girl named Linajah Brooker who was swept away by Chester Creek in Delaware County, Pennsylvania transitioned to a recovery mission. The decision was made on Sunday after the Coast Guard continued searching through the night while several fire companies took part in the initial search. Boats with thermal imaging were also used to scan the water on Saturday night while crews searched through nearby trees and debris.
The search for Linajah Brooker has transitioned from a search and rescue effort to a recovery effort as of Sunday.
Several fire companies took part in the search for Linajah while the Coast Guard continued searching through the night. Boats with thermal imaging were also used to scan the water on Saturday night while crews searched through nearby trees and debris.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(30%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the title of the article implies that a rescue effort was underway when it had already transitioned into a recovery effort. Secondly, Sarah Al-Arshani quotes Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley stating that they were looking for a miracle and hoping to find Linajah Brooker alive. However, later in the same article, Shirley states that they knew from the initial information it was going to be a recovery after three hours. This contradicts his earlier statement about hope and miracles. Lastly, there is no mention of any sources being disclosed or quoted which violates one of the ignore rules.
The title implies a rescue effort when it had already transitioned into a recovery effort.
Fallacies
(85%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Bias
(85%)
The article contains a statement from the Chester Fire Commissioner that they were looking for a 'miracle' to find the girl alive. This implies that there is no hope of finding her alive and therefore suggests bias towards an outcome rather than objectivity.
But that being said, we didn't want to give out hope. Because we were looking for that miracle.
]We always had in the back of our minds, just based on the initial information, that it was going be a recovery after three hours[
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Author
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
Sarah Al-Arshani has a conflict of interest on the topic of Chester Creek as she is reporting for USA Today which is owned by Gannett. Gannett also owns several other media outlets in Pennsylvania including The Philadelphia Inquirer and Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, both of which have reported extensively on the search and rescue effort for Linajah Brooker who fell into Chester Creek.
Sarah Al-Arshani reports for USA Today which is owned by Gannett. Gannett also owns several other media outlets in Pennsylvania including The Philadelphia Inquirer and Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, both of which have reported extensively on the search and rescue effort for Linajah Brooker who fell into Chester Creek.
Sarah Al-Arshani reports on the recovery effort for a 6 year old girl who fell into Pennsylvania creek. The article mentions that Gannett owns several other media outlets in Pennsylvania including The Philadelphia Inquirer and Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, both of which have reported extensively on the search and rescue effort for Linajah Brooker who fell into Chester Creek.
The search for a 6-year-old girl who was swept away in a rain-swollen southeastern Pennsylvania creek has become a recovery mission rather than a rescue mission.
Several fire companies took part in the search for Linajah Brooker while the Coast Guard continued searching through the night. Boats with thermal imaging were also used to scan the water on Saturday night while crews searched through nearby trees and debris.
Accuracy
No Contradictions at Time
Of
Publication
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the title of the article implies that it is a search and rescue mission when in fact it has become a recovery effort. Secondly, there are statements made by family members about Linajah Brooker's sister passing away on this exact day five years ago which could be seen as an attempt to manipulate emotions rather than providing relevant information. Thirdly, the article does not disclose any sources or quotes from experts in the field of water rescue and recovery.
The title of the article implies that it is a search and rescue mission when in fact it has become a recovery effort.
Fallacies
(85%)
The article contains several fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority by stating that Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley said the search has become a recovery mission rather than a rescue mission. This statement is not supported with any evidence or quotes from Shirley himself, making it unclear if he actually made such a statement. Additionally, the article contains inflammatory rhetoric by stating that family members are praying they find Linajah and that her grandmother's emotions are
The search for a 6-year-old girl who was swept away in a rain-swollen southeastern Pennsylvania creek has become a recovery mission rather than a rescue mission, authorities said Sunday.
The article contains a statement that the search for the missing girl has become a recovery mission rather than a rescue mission. This implies that there is no hope of finding her alive and therefore suggests bias towards accepting defeat.
]There's a lot of debris in the water which poses a potential hazard to our responders, but they've been trained to deal with those situations,
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
There are multiple examples of conflicts of interest in this article. The author has a personal relationship with Linajah Brooker and Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley as they were both involved in the search for the missing girl. Additionally, there is no disclosure about any financial ties or professional affiliations that may exist between these individuals and their roles in the incident.
The article mentions Linajah Brooker's involvement in a previous rescue operation with Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley.
Three girls were playing by Chester Creek in Delaware County when two of them slipped on the mud and fell into the water.
The girl's aunt, Tyeesha Reynolds, told NBC10 that her daughter tried holding onto the young girl’s jacket but couldn't and she got swept away into the creek.
Several of the girl's family members also jumped in the water and started searching on their own before crews arrived.
Accuracy
The search for Linajah Brooker has transitioned from a search and rescue effort to a recovery effort as of Sunday.
Several fire companies took part in the search for Linajah while the Coast Guard continued searching through the night.
Deception
(30%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that rescue crews are working again on Sunday morning to find a girl who fell into Chester Creek on Saturday night. However, this information is not accurate as the search was suspended after 10 p.m. on Saturday and there has been no update since then.
Rescue boats are in the water looking for the girl as the Coast Guard circles above the scene.
Fallacies
(70%)
The article contains several informal fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority when they quote officials stating that the girl is believed to still be in the water and that rescue boats are in the water looking for her. They also use inflammatory rhetoric by describing how dangerous it was for family members who jumped into the water on their own before crews arrived. Additionally, there is a dichotomous depiction of two girls slipping on mud and falling into the creek while one girl gets herself out safely.
Rescue boats are in the water looking for her.
Bias
(85%)
The article contains a statement that implies the girl who fell into the creek is believed to still be in the water. This suggests a bias towards assuming harm or danger for this child.
> One of those girls was able to get herself out, but the 6-year-old is believed to still be in the water,
The search for a 6-year-old girl swept away by Chester Creek in Delaware County has transitioned to a recovery mission.
On Saturday, initial reports indicated that two girls were playing by the water when Lin'Ajah slipped on mud and fell into the creek. The Chester Bureau of Fire then began a search and rescue operation in connection with Delaware County's water rescue team.
The U.S. Coast Guard also had a small boat and helicopter searching the area on Saturday.
On Sunday morning, smaller boats were deployed along the creek from where Lin'Ajah fell into the water to the mouth of the Delaware River.
Larger boats were used to search on both sides of the river in Chester and New Jersey.
Accuracy
On Sunday morning, smaller boats were deployed along the creek from where Lin'Ajah fell into the water to the mouth of the Delaware River. Larger boats were used to search on both sides of the river in Chester and New Jersey.
Deception
(50%)
The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, it states that the search for Lin’Ajah Brooker has transitioned to a recovery mission on Monday morning. However, this statement contradicts itself as there are no indications of any new information or evidence being found during the weekend that would warrant such a change in focus. Secondly, it quotes Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley stating that they were looking for Lin’Ajah's body after three hours and not hoping to find her alive. However, this statement is also contradicted by the fact that family members are still praying for her safe return. Lastly, it states that there is a desperate search for Lin’Ajah Brooker but does not provide any context or information about what makes the situation so urgent.
The article claims that the search has transitioned to a recovery mission on Monday morning, despite no new evidence being found during the weekend. This is deceptive because it implies that there was some sort of breakthrough in finding Lin’Ajah Brooker.
Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley states that they were looking for Lin’Ajah's body after three hours and not hoping to find her alive. However, this contradicts the fact that family members are still praying for her safe return.
Fallacies
(80%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Bias
(100%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (100%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Author
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
The author has a conflict of interest on the topic of Chester Creek as they are reporting on a search and rescue mission for Lin'Ajah Brooker who fell into the creek. The article also mentions that Delaware County officials have been involved in the recovery effort, which could further compromise their ability to report objectively.
The author reports on a search and rescue mission for Lin'Ajah Brooker who fell into Chester Creek. The article also mentions that Delaware County officials have been involved in the recovery effort, which could further compromise their ability to report objectively.
The City of Chester Mayor Stefan Roots is mentioned as being present at the scene of the incident and may be biased towards his city's interests.
The search for the girl has transitioned from a search and rescue effort to a recovery effort as of Sunday.
Several fire companies took part in the search for Linajah Brooker while the Coast Guard continued searching through the night. Boats with thermal imaging were also used to scan the water on Saturday night while crews searched through nearby trees and debris.
Accuracy
,
Several fire companies took part in the search for Linajah Brooker while the Coast Guard continued searching through the night.
Deception
(100%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Fallacies
(70%)
The article contains an appeal to authority fallacy when Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley states that the search for LinAjah Brooker is now a recovery mission. The author also uses inflammatory rhetoric by describing the situation as 'an extremely sad day' and stating that it was a miracle they were looking for, which implies an emotional bias.
Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley announced in a Sunday press conference that the search-and-rescue mission for LinAjah Brooker was now a recovery mission
The rainfall and debris in the water hampered the team's visibility on Saturday, and though it had cleared a little by Sunday morning, there was still no sign of Brooker
Bias
(85%)
None Found At Time Of
Publication
Site
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
Amanda Yen has a conflict of interest on the topic of Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley as she is reporting on his involvement in a search and rescue mission. She also has a conflict of interest on LinAjah Brooker as she mentions him multiple times without disclosing any potential ties.
Amanda Yen writes,
Author
Conflicts
Of
Interest (50%)
Amanda Yen has a conflict of interest on the topics of Chester Fire Commissioner John-Paul Shirley and LinAjah Brooker as she is reporting on their involvement in a search and rescue mission that turned into a recovery mission for a child swept away by a creek.
