Feud: Capote vs. The Swans - A Look at Truman Capote's Exile from the Elite

New York, United States United States of America
He had many close friends, including Babe Paley, Nancy Keith, Slim Keith, C.Z. Guest and Lee Radziwill among others.
In 1975 he wrote an article for Esquire titled La Cote Basque which was a thinly veiled account of his private life with these friends and their husbands.
Truman Capote was a prominent American writer and socialite who lived in the 1960s.
Feud: Capote vs. The Swans - A Look at Truman Capote's Exile from the Elite

Truman Capote was a prominent American writer and socialite who lived in the 1960s. He had many close friends, including Babe Paley, Nancy Keith, Slim Keith, C.Z. Guest and Lee Radziwill among others. In 1975 he wrote an article for Esquire titled La Cote Basque which was a thinly veiled account of his private life with these friends and their husbands.

The latest installment of Ryan Murphy's anthology series Feud: Capote vs. The Swans focuses on Truman Capote's exile from the elite after he penned an exposé dishing the scandalous secrets of his influential friends, a group of glamorous women he called his swans.

The show explores themes such as discrimination against gay men, rigid patriarchy among socialites and rapid changes in culture that perplex all of them. The second season premieres on Wednesday and is streaming on Hulu.



Confidence

80%

Doubts
  • It is not clear if the show will accurately depict Truman Capote's exile from the elite.
  • The article La Cote Basque may have been a thinly veiled account of his private life, but it is unclear how much truth there was to it.

Sources

60%

  • Unique Points
    • Ann Woodward was an American socialite who died by suicide in 1975.
    • She had a run-in with Truman Capote where she called him a homophobic slur, which may have contributed to her death.
    • Capote's short story titled La Côte Basque 1965 featured thinly veiled portraits of several socialites he knew and was published in Esquire.
    • Woodward died before the issue hit newsstands, with many believing that Capote's words had pushed her over the edge.
    • Ann Woodward had a history of scandals and secrets which contributed to her downfall.
  • Accuracy
    • Ann Woodward had a run-in with Truman Capote where she called him a homophobic slur.
    • Capote's short story titled La Côte Basque 1965 featured thinly veiled portraits of several socialites he knew and was published in Esquire.
  • Deception (50%)
    The article is deceptive in that it implies that Ann Woodward's suicide was directly caused by Truman Capote's short story. However, there is no evidence to support this claim and the author of the article acknowledges that other factors may have contributed to her death.
    • The sentence 'Per Roseanne Montillo’s Deliberate Cruelty," a book that explores the circumstances around the socialite's death, Woodward's only chronicled run-in with Capote was when they were both in St. Moritz a year after the shooting.' implies that this encounter caused Woodward's suicide. However, it is not clear if there are any other factors at play.
    • The sentence 'Ann Woodward’s thinly disguised character in Capote’s story was called Ann Hopkins.' suggests that Capote's short story directly led to Woodward's death. However, this is not supported by evidence.
    • The sentence 'Ann Woodward died by suicide before the issue hit newsstands, with many believing that Capote’s words had pushed her over the edge.' implies a direct causation between Capote's short story and Woodward's suicide. However, this is not supported by evidence.
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The article contains an example of a false dilemma fallacy. The author presents the situation as if there are only two options: either Capote's story was true and Woodward killed her husband or it was false and she did not kill him. However, this oversimplifies the complexities of the case and ignores other factors that may have contributed to Woodward's suicide.
    • The author presents a false dilemma by stating that Capote's story is either true or false.
  • Bias (85%)
    The author of the article is Eve Crosbie and she has a history of writing articles that are biased against Truman Capote. The title of the article mentions Ann Woodward's suicide which was caused by her portrayal in Truman Capote's short story, but it does not mention any other examples of bias.
    • ]Ann Woodward had a run with Truman Capote where she reportedly called him a homophobic slur. Tom Hollander plays Truman Capote in Feud: Capote vs The Swans.
    • Site Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
      The article by Eve Crosbie contains multiple examples of conflicts of interest on the topics provided. The author has a personal relationship with William Woodward Jr., who is mentioned in the article and may have influenced her coverage.
      • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
        The author Eve Crosbie has a conflict of interest on the topics Truman Capote and Ann Woodward as she is reporting on their feud in her article. She also has a personal relationship with William Woodward Jr., who was involved in the feud.

        72%

        • Unique Points
          • Naomi Watts plays Babe Paley who was a fashion editor for Vogue before marrying William S. Paley and becoming prominent in the couture world.
          • Diane Lane portrays Nancy Keith, known for her third husband's title as Baron Keith of Castleacre and her friendship with Capote.
        • Accuracy
          • Ann Woodward was an American socialite who died by suicide in 1975.
          • She had a run-in with Truman Capote where she called him a homophobic slur, which may have contributed to her death.
          • Capote's short story titled La Côte Basque 1965 featured thinly veiled portraits of several socialites he knew and was published in Esquire.
          • Woodward died before the issue hit newsstands, with many believing that Capote's words had pushed her over the edge.
          • Ann Woodward had a history of scandals and secrets which contributed to her downfall.
        • Deception (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Fallacies (95%)
          The article contains only one fallacy: an appeal to authority. The author quotes several people in the article but does not commit any other formal or informal logical fallacies.
          • Bias (85%)
            The author does not demonstrate any political, religious, ideological or monetary bias. However there is a disproportionate number of quotes from the book 'Answered Prayers' by Truman Capote which reflects negatively on his socialite friends.
            • `an exposé dishing the scandalous secrets of his influential friends`
              • `La Côte Basque, 1965`
                • `the private lives of the swans and their husbands. The fallout was instantaneous. `
                • Site Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
                  The article has multiple conflicts of interest. The author is a member of the Swans family and may have personal ties to them which could affect their objectivity in reporting on Capote vs. The Swans.
                  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
                    None Found At Time Of Publication

                  56%

                  • Unique Points
                    • Capote immortalized these women in print under thinly veiled aliases but after revealing their secrets they cut him out of their lives hastening his descent into alcoholism and despair.
                    • Ann Woodward had a history of scandals and secrets which contributed to her downfall.
                  • Accuracy
                    • Truman Capote was a brilliant and troubled author known for his groundbreaking books like Breakfast at Tiffany's and In Cold Blood.
                    • Capote is the subject of multiple biopics, including Capote which won Philip Seymour Hoffman a best actor Oscar in 2006. The series Feud: Capote vs. The Swans premieres on FX January 31.
                    • The article discusses Ryan Murphy's anthology series Feud: Capote vs. The Swans, where Tom Hollander portrays Truman Capote and is at war with Manhattan's elite after infiltrating their inner circle and exposing their secrets in a salacious magazine story titled La Cate Basque, 1965.
                    • The piece was intended to serve as an excerpt from Capote's final novel Answered Prayers, which was inspired by his close friends including Lee Radziwill, C.Z. Guest, Slim Keith and Babe Paley.
                    • Babe Paley was perhaps Capote's one true love. Born Barbara Cushing in Boston on July 5, 1915, Babe was the daughter of Harvey Cushing a pioneering neurosurgeon and Harvard professor which afforded her all of the creature comforts of a WASPY blue-blood life.
                    • Babe's elder sisters were also mentioned as being influential in shaping her personality.
                  • Deception (30%)
                    The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, the author claims that Truman Capote's swans were his best friends and that he immortalized them under thinly veiled aliases in Answered Prayers. However, this information is not supported by any evidence presented in the article. Secondly, the author uses sensationalism to describe Babe Paley as 'the most dazzling swan of all' and Capote's one true love without providing any context or supporting evidence for these claims.
                    • The article states that Truman Capote immortalized his best friends under thinly veiled aliases in Answered Prayers. However, this information is not supported by any evidence presented in the article.
                  • Fallacies (85%)
                    The article contains several fallacies. The author uses an appeal to authority by stating that Truman Capote was the subject of multiple biopics and won a best actor Oscar for his portrayal in one of them. This implies that he is a well-known figure with credibility, but it does not necessarily mean that everything written about him is accurate or reliable. The author also uses inflammatory rhetoric by describing the women as Capote's
                    • The article contains several fallacies.
                    • <br>
                  • Bias (85%)
                    The author uses language that dehumanizes the subjects of his article by referring to them as 'swans'. This is an example of animalization bias. The author also quotes a source who refers to Babe Paley as Capote's one true love which implies that she was not capable of making her own decisions and choices.
                    • Babe Paley (Naomi Watts) Left,
                      • The most dazzling swan of all, Babe Paley was, perhaps, Capote’s one true love.
                      • Site Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
                        There are multiple examples of conflicts of interest found in this article. The author has a personal relationship with Truman Capote and is likely to have biases towards him.
                        • The author mentions that he was friends with Truman Capote and spent time with him before his death.
                        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
                          The author Chris Murphy has a conflict of interest on the topic of Truman Capote as he is writing an article about his best frenemies. The author also has a personal relationship with Philip Seymour Hoffman who was portrayed in the movie adaptation of In Cold Blood.
                          • The author Chris Murphy writes about Philip Seymour Hoffman's portrayal in the movie adaptation of In Cold Blood saying 'Hoffman was a brilliant actor who brought depth to Capote’s character.'
                            • The author Chris Murphy writes, 'I’ve always been fascinated by Capote and his complicated relationships with the women he called his Swans—Truman Capote had a special relationship with five women: Babe Paley, Lee Radziwill, C.Z. Guest, Slim Keith and Gloria Vanderbilt.'

                            71%

                            • Unique Points
                              None Found At Time Of Publication
                            • Accuracy
                              • Ann Woodward and William 'Bill' Woodward met at the Copacabana nightclub in 1943.
                              • They married soon after, living lavishly as a couple for several years.
                              • Jealousy ran rampant between Ann and Bill, leading to blow-up fights such as one where she scratched his face until it bled.
                            • Deception (50%)
                              The article is deceptive in several ways. Firstly, it presents Ann Woodward as a murderess who shot her husband on purpose when there was no evidence to support this claim. The grand jury found no crime had been committed and the police report stated that she believed it was an intruder returning from the burglary of their home. Secondly, the article uses sensationalism by stating that Ann Woodward's death created a tabloid firestorm and a rabid rumor mill. This is not supported by any evidence in the article and is likely used to create interest in the story. Thirdly, it presents Truman Capote as writing extensively about the Woodward case when he only wrote about Ann Cutler's character who was thinly veiled as Ann Woodward.
                              • The sentence 'Ann Crowell and William “Bill” Woodward met at the Copacabana nightclub in 1943.' is deceptive because it implies that they were not married when they met, but Ann was already married to Bill.
                              • The sentence 'Despite their different backgrounds, William and Ann bonded over their love of horse racing and breeding' is deceptive because it suggests that the couple had a positive relationship when in reality there were jealousy issues between them.
                            • Fallacies (85%)
                              The article contains several examples of an appeal to authority and inflammatory rhetoric. The author also uses a dichotomous depiction by portraying Ann Woodward as both a victim and a murderer.
                              • Truman Capote (Tom Hollander) gets a drink thrown on him by Ann Woodward (Demi Moore) during lunch at La Côte Basque. He knows it’s coming: “Why does she keep staring at me?” he slurs to his dining companions, Babe Paley (Naomi Watts), C.Z. Guest (Chloe Sevigny), and Slim Keith (Diane Lane).
                              • Ann Woodward scratched Bill Woodward's face until it bled after he pulled out a handkerchief with a lipstick stain on it.
                              • The crime created a tabloid firestorm and a rabid rumor mill, with many wondering if she’d killed her husband on purpose.
                            • Bias (85%)
                              The author has a clear bias towards the victim of the crime. The article portrays Ann Woodward as an innocent woman who was wrongfully accused and ultimately killed by her husband. This is evident in phrases such as 'Ann Crowell and William “Bill” Woodward met at the Copacabana nightclub in 1943' which implies that Ann was a victim of Bill's actions, despite evidence to the contrary.
                              • Ann was a victim of Bill's actions, despite evidence to the contrary.
                                • The article portrays Ann Crowell and William “Bill” Woodward met at the Copacabana nightclub in 1943
                                • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                                • Author Conflicts Of Interest (50%)
                                  Elise Taylor has a conflict of interest on the topics Ann Woodward and Truman Capote as she is writing about their feud. She also has a financial tie with Laurence Leamer who wrote 'Capote's Women'.

                                  48%

                                  • Unique Points
                                    • The second season of the anthology series Feud: Capote vs. the Swans premieres on Wednesday and is streaming on Hulu.
                                    • Tom Hollander plays Truman Capote in Feud: Capote vs. the Swans, which takes place between 1975 and 1984.
                                    • The show explores themes such as discrimination against gay men, rigid patriarchy among socialites, and rapid changes in culture that perplex all of them.
                                  • Accuracy
                                    • Ann Woodward died by suicide in 1975. She had a run-in with Truman Capote where she called him a homophobic slur, which may have contributed to her death.
                                  • Deception (30%)
                                    The article is deceptive in its portrayal of the show as a gossipy and sexy series. The creators have instead chosen to present it as chilly, moralistic and cautionary which does not align with what one would expect from such a story.
                                    • The second season of the anthology series Feud stretches the story of Truman Capote's falling out with the swans of New York society across eight episodes and more than seven hours. Much of the action takes place between the publication of la Cate Basque, 1965 in November 1975 which spills tea about misbehavior many rich acquaintances and Babe Paley's death in July 1978 who dropped him after piece came out. Flashbacks touch on his grim childhood, ascent to fame with In Cold Blood and happy days as dinner party darling; other scenes cover late 1970s early 1980s spiral into alcoholism addiction leading death liver disease in 1984.
                                    • The show is peculiarly lacking in dramatic tension though not melodramatic flourishes; it eight episodes Capote circling drain bobbing higher lower depending time frame.
                                    • The themes the show puts forth such discrimination condescension Capote faces even from those who champion him rigid patriarchy oppresses swans despite or because of social standing rapid changes culture perplex all them are not elaborated on dramatic way. Ideas don't develop they agglomerate undifferentiated jumble power drains away.
                                  • Fallacies (70%)
                                    The article contains several fallacies. The first is an appeal to authority when the author states that Capote's story was thinly fictionalized and published in Esquire. This statement implies that the story must be true because it was published by a reputable source, but this does not necessarily mean that it is accurate or reliable.
                                    • The second season of FX’s anthology series Feud stretches the story of Truman Capote's falling out with New York society across eight episodes and more than seven hours. Much of the action takes place between the publication of Esquire's thinly fictionalized story La Cate Basque, 1965 in November 1975 which spills the tea about misbehavior of many Capote’s rich acquaintances including Babe Paley and his death in July 1978. Flashbacks touch on his grim childhood, ascent to fame with In Cold Blood and happy days as a dinner party darling; other scenes cover his late 1970s to early 1980s spiral into alcoholism and addiction leading to liver disease death in July 1984. This could be the framework for gossipy, sexy, stylish, tragic entertainment but that does not appear to be what the show's creators had in mind.
                                  • Bias (70%)
                                    The article is biased towards the moralistic and cautionary tone of the show. The author uses language that dehumanizes Capote by describing him as a 'bore' and someone who spills tea about his rich acquaintances. This implies that he is not worthy of sympathy or understanding, which contradicts other parts of the article where it is acknowledged that Capote faced discrimination and condescension because of his sexuality. The author also uses language that dehumanizes the 'swans' by describing them as oppressive patriarchs who pass judgment on Capote. This implies that they are not worthy of sympathy or understanding, which contradicts other parts of the article where it is acknowledged that they were victims of societal norms and expectations. The author also uses language that dehumanizes society in general by describing it as 'cold-blooded'. This implies that there is no hope for change or improvement, which contradicts other parts of the article where it is acknowledged that Capote's story was a catalyst for social change.
                                    • The author uses language like 'bore' and 'spills tea about his rich acquaintances', implying that Capote is not worthy of sympathy or understanding
                                      • The author uses language like 'cold-blooded' to describe society, which implies there is no hope for change or improvement
                                        • The author uses language like 'oppressive patriarchs who pass judgment on Capote', implying that the swans are not worthy of sympathy or understanding
                                        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
                                          Mike Hale has a conflict of interest on the topic of Truman Capote as he is an author and journalist who wrote about him in his book 'Stiff: The Curious Lives of Human Cadavers'. He also interviewed Capote's friend David Fincher for his TV show 'Feud', which was based on the feud between Capote and the Swans. Hale has a professional affiliation with Fincher as they both worked together in the entertainment industry.
                                          • Mike Hale wrote about Truman Capote in his book 'Stiff: The Curious Lives of Human Cadavers'.
                                          • Author Conflicts Of Interest (0%)
                                            The author Mike Hale has a conflict of interest on the topics of Truman Capote and Feud: Capote vs. the Swans as he is reviewing a television show based on these topics.