Hamas' Guerrilla Warfare Tactics and Exploitation of Civilian Institutions in the Conflict in Gaza

Gaza, Gaza Strip Palestine, State of
Al-Ahli Hospital was evacuated independently, resulting in dozens of patients being transferred out
Hamas fighters disguise themselves as civilians to attack Israeli forces
Hamas uses guerrilla warfare tactics, hiding weapons and fighters in civilian areas and infrastructure
International law prohibits Hamas from using civilian objects for military purposes
Hamas' Guerrilla Warfare Tactics and Exploitation of Civilian Institutions in the Conflict in Gaza

The conflict in Gaza has taken a dire turn as Hamas employs guerrilla warfare tactics, using civilians and civilian infrastructure to hide weapons, fighters, and launch surprise attacks on Israeli forces. The organization's military wing, the Qassam Brigades, has acted as a decentralized force hiding in tunnels and residential neighborhoods throughout Gaza. Hamas fighters have disguised themselves as civilians or worn plainclothes before firing on Israeli troops or attaching mines to their vehicles. They have also rigged abandoned homes with explosives and tripwires, often luring Israeli soldiers into these buildings by scattering signs of a Hamas presence. In contrast to its October 7 attack on Israel, which began with a coordinated large-scale maneuver involving thousands of uniformed commandos, most Hamas fighters have retreated from their bases and outposts in an attempt to evade Israel's technological and numerical advantage. From below ground, Hamas's ghost army has appeared only fleetingly, emerging suddenly from a warren of tunnels armed with rocket-propelled grenades before swiftly returning to their subterranean fortress. In some cases, they have hidden among the few civilians who decided to remain in their neighborhoods despite Israeli orders to evacuate or accompanied civilians as they returned to areas that the Israelis had captured and then abandoned. Despite the heavy civilian casualties in Gaza, Hamas's strategy has helped the organization achieve some of its objectives, including damaging Israel's reputation in many parts of the world, deepening divisions within Israeli society, and bringing the question of Palestinian statehood back into global discourse. As Hamas continues to employ these tactics, the conflict in Gaza is likely to worsen and result in further suffering for both Israeli soldiers and Palestinian civilians.

In addition to its use of guerrilla warfare tactics, Hamas has exploited civilian institutions as leverage in the conflict. Al-Ahli Hospital was evacuated independently despite military messages stating it was unnecessary, resulting in patients being transferred to Indonesian Hospital and emptying it of dozens of patients. Hamas has also used schools, mosques, UN facilities, and hospitals for military purposes, further blurring the line between civilians and combatants. International law prohibits the use of civilian objects for military objectives by Hamas. As the conflict continues to escalate, it is crucial to hold Hamas accountable for its actions and ensure that international law is upheld in order to minimize harm to innocent civilians and bring about a just resolution to the conflict.

As part of its military operations, Israel has killed more than 14,000 out of 25,000 Hamas fighters. If accurate, this would leave thousands of Hamas fighters still active. These remaining fighters continue to employ guerrilla tactics and use civilian infrastructure for military purposes in their efforts to resist Israeli forces. Despite the challenges posed by Hamas's tactics, Israel has been successful in its efforts to limit the organization's capabilities and minimize harm to civilians. The IDF has worked tirelessly to locate and neutralize Hamas tunnels, booby-traps, and hidden weapons stores while also providing humanitarian aid to the people of Gaza. As the conflict continues, Israel will remain committed to protecting its citizens and upholding international law while working towards a peaceful resolution in the region.

In conclusion, Hamas's use of guerrilla warfare tactics and exploitation of civilian institutions has deepened the despair in Gaza and prolonged the conflict. As long as Hamas continues to employ these tactics, the suffering of both Israeli soldiers and Palestinian civilians is likely to persist. It is essential that international law be upheld, and Hamas be held accountable for its actions in order to bring about a just resolution to the conflict.



Confidence

85%

Doubts
  • The accuracy of the number of Hamas fighters killed by Israel
  • The exact number of civilians affected by Hamas's use of civilian institutions for military purposes

Sources

77%

  • Unique Points
    • Hamas uses guerrilla warfare tactics in Gaza
    • Hamas has an extensive tunnel network
    • Hamas hides weapons and fighters in civilian infrastructure
    • International law prohibits use of civilian infrastructure for military purposes by Hamas
  • Accuracy
    No Contradictions at Time Of Publication
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (85%)
    The author makes several implicit appeals to authority by citing a report from The New York Times and quoting Israeli military officials. However, these appeals do not directly contribute to logical fallacies in the article as they are presented as evidence or supporting information rather than being used as premises for an argument. Additionally, there are instances of dichotomous depiction when describing Hamas tactics and their impact on civilians in Gaza. For example, the author states that 'Hamas' strategy aims to prolong the fighting and intensify international criticism of Israel, even at the cost of ongoing harm to Palestinian civilians.' This statement implies a false dichotomy between prolonging the conflict and causing harm to civilians, when in reality these two things are not mutually exclusive. Furthermore, there are instances of inflammatory rhetoric used throughout the article such as 'systematic exploitation', 'blurring the line between civilians and combatants', and 'contribute to ongoing destruction'. These phrases may be emotionally charged but do not necessarily constitute logical fallacies.
    • ]Hamas' strategy aims to prolong the fighting and intensify international criticism of Israel, even at the cost of ongoing harm to Palestinian civilians.[
    • The report reveals that Hamas terrorists wear civilian clothes, sometimes sandals or tracksuits, before firing at IDF soldiers.
  • Bias (0%)
    The article by Ynet demonstrates a clear bias against Hamas by reporting on their use of civilian infrastructure for military purposes and the resulting harm to Palestinian civilians. The author does not provide any counter-argument or perspective from Hamas, instead focusing solely on the negative implications of their tactics. This one-sided reporting is an example of biased journalism.
    • According to the report, Hamas hides terrorists, tunnel shafts and ammunition depots in residential buildings, medical facilities, UN offices and mosques
      • Hamas terrorists wear civilian clothes before firing at IDF soldiers or launching rockets from civilian areas
        • They also booby-trap abandoned houses with explosives and lure soldiers into these buildings by leaving signs indicating the presence of belligerents
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication

        97%

        • Unique Points
          • Hamas overwhelmed Israel’s border in October with a coordinated, large-scale maneuver before committing atrocities.
          • , Hamas fighters often disguise themselves as civilians.
          • Israeli soldiers have found Hamas tunnels near the Erez border crossing in Gaza.
          • Hamas fighters hide under residential neighborhoods and store weapons in miles of tunnels and houses, mosques, sofas, and even a child’s bedroom.
          • , Hamas fighters emerge from hiding to fire on Israeli troops or attach mines to their vehicles.
          • Hamas rigs abandoned homes with explosives and tripwires.
          • Most Hamas fighters have retreated from their bases and outposts, seeking to blunt Israel’s technological and numerical advantage by launching surprise attacks on small groups of soldiers.
          • From below ground, Hamas’ ghost army has appeared suddenly from a warren of tunnels armed with rocket-propelled grenades.
          • Some Hamas fighters hide among civilians or accompany them as they return to areas that the Israelis have captured and then abandoned.
        • Accuracy
          • Hamas overwhelmed Israel's border in October with a coordinated, large-scale maneuver before committing atrocities.
          • Hamas fighters often disguise themselves as civilians.
        • Deception (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Fallacies (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Bias (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication
        • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
          None Found At Time Of Publication

        60%

        • Unique Points
          • Hamas uses civilian homes to conceal fighters, tunnel entrances, booby-traps, and ammunition stores.
          • , Hamas fighters dress as civilians and hide beneath the ground in an extensive network of tunnels to ambush Israeli soldiers.
          • Hamas has enough food rations in the tunnels for at least ten months.
          • , Hamas terrorists track IDF soldiers’ locations using hidden cameras, drones, and civilian lookouts including children.
          • , Hamas squads allow Israeli soldiers to roam freely for hours or even days in areas marked for attack before emerging from tunnels to attack and booby-trap the area.
          • Hamas fighters had been preparing for a ground war since at least 2021 by increasing production of explosives and anti-tank missiles and stopping making so many long-range rockets.
          • , Hamas has a landline telephone network in the tunnels that is difficult for Israel to monitor, allowing terrorists to communicate even during outages to Gaza’s mobile phone networks.
          • Hamas fighters use chained dogs, Israeli clothing or identification cards, and dead bodies rigged with explosives as traps for IDF soldiers.
          • , International law requires combatants to avoid using civilian objects for military objectives including homes, schools, hospitals, and mosques.
        • Accuracy
          • Hamas fighters dress as civilians and hide beneath the ground in an extensive network of tunnels to ambush Israeli soldiers.
        • Deception (30%)
          The article provides detailed descriptions of Hamas' use of civilian homes and infrastructure to conceal fighters, tunnel entrances, booby-traps, and ammunition stores. This is a clear example of selective reporting as it only reports details that support the author's position. The article also implies that Hamas uses civilians as lookouts and leaves secret signals outside homes to indicate the presence of mines or weapons caches. These actions can be considered emotional manipulation and sensationalism as they aim to evoke strong emotions in readers by portraying Hamas as a ruthless and dangerous organization that does not care about civilian lives. The article also states that Hamas fighters dress as civilians, which is a common tactic used by resistance movements, but it fails to mention that this is allowed under international law. However, the article does mention that disguising combatants in civilian clothing to commit hostilities constitutes perfidy under international law.
          • To help fellow Hamas members find these weapons caches inside civilian homes, several Israeli soldiers said, Hamas has developed a system of code for marking houses that contain weapons, tunnels, or booby trap.
          • Hamas uses civilian homes and infrastructure, including medical facilities, UN facilities, and mosques, to conceal fighters, tunnel entrances, booby-traps, and ammunition stores.
          • Soldiers sometimes entered houses by blowing a hole in their walls in case the front doors were rigged with mines.
        • Fallacies (75%)
          The article provides a detailed account of Hamas's use of guerrilla tactics in their conflict with Israel, including the use of civilian homes to stockpile weapons and disguising fighters as civilians. The article also discusses Hamas's extensive tunnel network and their strategy of hiding from Israeli forces in order to launch surprise attacks. While the author does not explicitly condone these tactics, they do provide a comprehensive overview of Hamas's methods.
          • Hamas uses civilian homes to stockpile weapons, dresses its fighters as civilians and moves through an extensive tunnel network to sneak up on and ambush Israeli soldiers.
        • Bias (5%)
          The author uses language that depicts Hamas as hiding in civilian areas and using civilians to carry out attacks, implying a moral superiority on the part of the Israeli forces. This is an example of bias through framing.
          • At other times, Israeli troops were lured inside by a piece of Israeli clothing or identification card.
            • Hamas fighters dress as civilians, store weapons in civilian homes, in mosques, in the linings of sofas, in the walls of children's bedrooms, and hide beneath the ground in an extensive network of tunnels.
              • Hamas uses civilian homes to conceal fighters, tunnel entrances, booby-traps, and ammunition stores.
                • The New York Times conducted its analysis using Hamas-released battlefield videos, interviews with three Hamas members, and interviews with many Israeli soldiers. Based on these sources, the Times concluded that Hamas's strategy of hiding includes using hundreds of miles of tunnels to move around Gaza without being seen by Israeli soldiers and using civilian homes and infrastructure to conceal fighters.
                • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication

                89%

                • Unique Points
                  • Hamas has been using civilian institutions in areas where IDF operates in Gaza as leverage.
                  • Al-Ahli Hospital was evacuated independently despite military messages stating it was unnecessary.
                  • Patients from Al-Ahli Hospital were transferred to Indonesian Hospital, emptying it of dozens of patients.
                • Accuracy
                  • During another evacuation, hundreds of patients from European Hospital were ordered to evacuate and ultimately transferred to various hospitals in the Gaza Strip where looters arrived and stole equipment.
                • Deception (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Fallacies (95%)
                  The author makes several assertions about Hamas using hospitals as leverage without providing clear evidence that it was Hamas who made the decisions to evacuate the hospitals. This is an example of an Appeal to Authority fallacy, as the author assumes that because security officials deny the necessity of evacuating certain hospitals, it must be Hamas making those decisions. Additionally, there are instances where the author reports conflicting information about whether or not a shelter was hit in one instance and an independent evacuation occurred in another. This could potentially be an example of a Dichotomous Depiction fallacy if it is being implied that there are only two possibilities (either the IDF or Hamas is responsible for these actions) when there may be other explanations. However, without more information, it's difficult to definitively say that this is a fallacy.
                  • ]There is a growing trend of exploiting and using civilian institutions as leverage in a legitimacy battle against Israel, disrupting the functioning of the health system, particularly hospitals[
                  • This is yet another cynical exploitation of the population, likely carried out by terrorist organizations in the Strip, including Hamas.
                • Bias (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication
                • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
                  None Found At Time Of Publication