Newly Discovered Chimpanzee Recordings Suggest Complex Vocal Capabilities, Challenging Previous Assumptions About Speech Evolution

Palm Harbor, Florida, Florida United States of America
Johnny and Renata were able to add vowels after consonants in their vocalizations.
This ability suggests that chimpanzees may possess the neural building blocks necessary for speech.
Two chimpanzees, Johnny and Renata, have uttered the word 'mama' in recordings.
Newly Discovered Chimpanzee Recordings Suggest Complex Vocal Capabilities, Challenging Previous Assumptions About Speech Evolution

Two chimpanzees, Johnny and Renata, have been discovered to have uttered the word 'mama' in recordings from the past. This finding sheds light on the evolution of human speech and challenges previous assumptions about great apes' vocal capabilities.

Johnny and Renata were able to add vowels after consonants in their vocalizations, a skill that was not present in previous attempts to teach chimpanzees speech. This ability suggests that chimpanzees may possess the neural building blocks necessary for speech, as humans and chimpanzees share 98.8% of the same DNA.

The discovery of Johnny and Renata's vocalizations comes from re-examining old research and a recent find on YouTube. The researchers involved in the study believe that this finding offers important insights into the origins of human speech, as talking allowed early humans to cooperate and amass knowledge over generations.

Despite earlier experiments, such as those involving Viki, a chimpanzee raised by psychologist Keith Hayes and his wife in the 1940s, being dismissed due to trauma inflicted on the animals and lack of conclusive results, Johnny and Renata's vocalizations demonstrate that chimpanzees may be capable of more complex vocalizations than previously thought.

Recent research has shown other ways that chimpanzees act like humans. For example, mother chimps prioritize playing with their children even when food is scarce and they are exhausted.

Chimpanzees' vocal abilities challenge the reputation of great apes as unsuitable models for speech and language evolution. This discovery may lead to further research into the origins of human speech and how it evolved from our closest living relatives.



Confidence

85%

Doubts
  • It is unclear if the researchers have definitively proven that Johnny and Renata were not mimicking human speech.
  • The sample size of this study is small, with only two chimpanzees being studied.

Sources

91%

  • Unique Points
    • Johnny and Renata could add vowels after consonants in their vocalizations unlike previous attempts at teaching chimpanzees speech.
  • Accuracy
    • Two chimpanzees, Johnny and Renata, were recorded saying ‘mama’ according to old videos.
    • Chimpanzees have the neural building blocks necessary for speech as demonstrated by their ability to produce syllabic sounds.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (95%)
    The author makes several statements in the article that are not fallacious. However, there is one instance of an appeal to authority when the author states '“Great ape vocal production capacities have been underestimated. Chimpanzees possess the neural building blocks necessary for speech.”' This statement is made based on the research conducted by other scientists and not from any personal experience or evidence provided by the author. Therefore, I am deducting 5 points from the score.
    • '“Great ape vocal production capacities have been underestimated. Chimpanzees possess the neural building blocks necessary for speech.”
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

91%

  • Unique Points
    • Talking allowed early humans to cooperate and amass knowledge over generations
    • Researchers believe that our common ancestors with chimpanzees had brains equipped with some of the building blocks needed for talking
    • Viki, a chimpanzee raised by psychologist Keith Hayes and his wife in the 140s, was able to say ‘papa’, ‘mama’, ‘up’ and ‘cup’ after two years of training
  • Accuracy
    • ]Two chimpanzees, Johnny and Renata, were recorded saying ['mama'] according to old videos.[
    • Chimpanzees in the wild do not produce ['cup']-like or ['mama']-like utterances.
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (95%)
    The author makes several statements that are not fallacious. However, there is an instance of an appeal to authority when the author quotes Adriano Lameira stating that 'Talking to each other allowed early humans to cooperate and amass knowledge over generations.' This statement is not a logical conclusion based on the evidence provided in the article, but rather an opinion by Lameira. Therefore, I can only give a score of 95.
    • 'Talking to each other allowed early humans to cooperate and amass knowledge over generations.' - Adriano Lameira
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication

87%

  • Unique Points
    • Chimpanzees in the wild do not produce 'cup'-like or 'mama'-like utterances
    • Chimpanzees are challenging the reputation of great apes as unsuitable models for speech and language evolution
  • Accuracy
    • The interpretation that no nonhuman primates have ever been trained to produce speech sounds has become a prevailing belief
    • Voiced labial articulations, such as 'mama', are among the first words to emerge in human infants during canonical babbling
  • Deception (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Fallacies (95%)
    The author makes several arguments in this article, but the primary fallacy present is an appeal to ignorance. The author states that chimpanzees do not produce 'cup' or 'mama'-like utterances and uses this as evidence against their vocal production learning abilities. However, the absence of evidence for these specific utterances does not prove that chimpanzees are incapable of vocal production learning. Additionally, the author makes assumptions about great apes lacking key neural circuitry based on the belief that they have never been trained to produce speech sounds. This is an unwarranted assumption and a logical fallacy as it ignores direct evidence of vocal learning in non-human primates and relies solely on second-hand accounts and lack of evidence for specific instances of speech production.
    • ]The interpretation that 'despite repeated attempts, no nonhuman primates have ever been trained to produce speech sounds, not even chimpanzees raised from birth in human homes'[/ has led to extrapolations that great apes lack key neural circuitry for voluntary motor control over the voice and articulators (i.e., lip, tongue, jaws)[
    • Chimpanzees in the wild do not produce any 'cup'-like or 'mama'-like utterances
  • Bias (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Site Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication
  • Author Conflicts Of Interest (100%)
    None Found At Time Of Publication